Friday, February 28, 2025

A Great Conversation with Robert Plank Marketer of the Day Show

 


About the Show:
In this episode of Marketer of the Day, we have David Barnett, an author, speaker, educator seminar host, consultant, and a business buy and sell coach. He guides people all over the world who want to buy or sell companies. David has written a variety of books and educational courses for small businesses. One of his books has become a best-seller on Amazon. He also consults with company leaders on how to develop their operations, administration, and processes. In this episode, we'll talk about how to start a company, get started, and cope with mistakes business owners make. We'll also go into the advantages of owning a company and how the pandemic changed the business world.

Wednesday, February 26, 2025

Small Business Mergers

 

How to Merge Two Small Businesses: Valuation, Shares & Ownership Explained

What happens when two small business owners decide they'd be better off working together?

Instead of one person buying the other person's business for cash, they could combine their companies into one larger operation.

Both owners could receive shares in the combined business, share in its future profits, and potentially benefit from the advantages of operating together.

That's called a business merger.

But how do you actually merge two small businesses?

How do you determine what each company is worth?

And if you're paying for the merger with shares instead of cash, how do you calculate how much ownership each person should receive?

These are important questions because merging two businesses isn't simply a matter of combining their customers and employees.

You're also combining financial obligations, operating systems, management responsibilities, and business relationships.

And perhaps most importantly, you're entering into a long-term business relationship with another owner.

After spending years discussing buying, selling, financing, and managing small and medium-sized businesses, I realized I'd never devoted an entire video to mergers.

That changed when I received a question from Craig.

He wanted to merge his business with another company and compensate the other owner using shares.

His question was straightforward: How do you determine what those shares are worth?

Let's walk through the process.


What Is a Small Business Merger?

A merger occurs when two businesses combine their operations or ownership interests to create a larger business arrangement.

In a traditional acquisition, one company purchases another.

The seller receives compensation and may leave the business entirely.

But in the type of merger Craig was considering, both existing owners would remain shareholders in the combined operation.

Instead of one owner receiving cash and walking away, both owners would contribute their businesses and receive ownership interests reflecting the value they bring.

Is a Merger the Same as a Partnership?

From a practical perspective, a merger can resemble a partnership.

Two owners agree to work together, share responsibilities, and participate in the financial results.

However, the legal structure may be a corporation, limited liability company, or another type of entity, depending on the jurisdiction.

The important distinction is that both owners retain an economic interest in the combined business.

And that creates some important considerations.

Before you start discussing shares and valuations, you need to determine whether the two owners can actually work together.

The 5 Types of Business Mergers

Not every merger serves the same strategic purpose.

Some businesses merge to reduce competition.

Others want access to new markets, products, suppliers, or customers.

Here are five common categories.

1. Horizontal Merger

A horizontal merger involves two companies operating in the same industry and providing similar products or services.

For example, imagine two trucking companies.

Each operates tractor-trailers and serves commercial customers.

They decide to combine their operations into one larger transportation business.

The merger may allow them to share administrative resources, improve equipment utilization, or serve more customers.

2. Vertical Merger

A vertical merger involves companies operating at different stages of the same supply chain.

For example, a manufacturer might merge with a distributor that sells its products.

Instead of operating as separate businesses, they combine their activities.

This could improve coordination between production and distribution.

3. Conglomerate Merger

A conglomerate merger involves businesses operating in unrelated industries.

Imagine a window manufacturing company combining with a party supply retailer.

Their products and customers may have little in common.

The strategic rationale would need to come from some other benefit, such as financial diversification or shared ownership objectives.

4. Market Extension Merger

A market extension merger involves businesses operating in the same industry but serving different geographical markets.

For example, a company based in New York might merge with a similar business in California.

This could provide access to customers in a new region without requiring either company to build its operations there from scratch.

5. Product Extension Merger

A product extension merger combines businesses offering related but different products.

For example, a window manufacturer might merge with a door manufacturer.

The companies may serve similar customers.

They could potentially cross-sell products and combine sales or distribution activities.

Comparing the Five Merger Types

Merger typeExamplePotential strategic benefit
HorizontalTwo trucking companiesGreater scale and shared operations
VerticalManufacturer and distributorBetter supply chain coordination
ConglomerateWindow factory and party supply storeDiversification
Market extensionNew York and California businessesGeographic expansion
Product extensionWindow and door manufacturersCross-selling related products

The merger type helps explain why the companies want to combine.

But identifying the strategic benefit is only the beginning.

Step 1: Develop a Strategic Plan for the Combined Business

Before discussing valuations, the two owners need to agree on why the merger makes sense.

What will the combined business accomplish that the two separate businesses cannot?

Will it reduce costs?

Create new sales opportunities?

Improve operational efficiency?

Allow one owner to retire?

Or provide access to new markets?

Both parties need to understand the intended benefits.

Create an Organizational Chart

One of the first things I would recommend is creating an organizational chart for the combined company.

Who will be responsible for sales?

Who will manage employees?

Who will oversee operations?

Who will handle finances?

And who will make important decisions?

These questions may seem obvious, but they're essential.

Two successful business owners may have very different management styles.

If both expect to remain in charge of the same responsibilities, the relationship could become difficult.

Develop a Business Plan

I would also recommend preparing a business plan for the combined operation.

This should explain how the businesses will work together.

It should identify the intended operational changes and establish the responsibilities of each owner.

My program Build a Business That People Will Want to Buy, available through Easy Small Biz Systems, addresses the development of organizational structures, systems, and management responsibilities.

Those same principles can be useful when preparing two businesses to merge.

A successful merger needs a clear operating plan, not just an agreement about ownership percentages.

Step 2: Conduct Due Diligence on Both Businesses

Once the owners agree that merging could be beneficial, the next step is due diligence.

This is particularly important because both parties are contributing significant value to the new arrangement.

Why Both Owners Need to Investigate Each Other

In a traditional acquisition, the buyer investigates the company being purchased.

But in a merger, both owners are effectively becoming investors in the combined operation.

Each person needs to understand what the other is contributing.

That means examining financial statements, assets, liabilities, customer relationships, contracts, and operating risks.

You also need to investigate whether the businesses have obligations that could create problems after the merger.

Don't Forget Due Diligence on the Other Owner

Financial due diligence isn't enough.

You also need to determine whether you can work with the other person.

I've seen business partnerships break down.

When that happens, the owners may need to negotiate a buyout or dissolve the relationship.

A merger can make that situation even more complicated because both parties have contributed established businesses.

You're potentially putting years of accumulated value into a new shared arrangement.

That's why I would spend significant time discussing management philosophy, financial expectations, and decision-making responsibilities.

Important Due Diligence Questions

Before proceeding, investigate:

  • The financial condition of both companies.

  • Outstanding debts and other liabilities.

  • Customer concentration and major contracts.

  • Employee responsibilities and compensation.

  • Existing operating systems.

  • Legal disputes and regulatory obligations.

  • The management styles of both owners.

  • Expectations about future distributions and compensation.

  • What happens if one owner wants to leave.

The last question is particularly important.

Even if the relationship begins positively, circumstances can change.

The owners should consider how future disagreements, retirement, or ownership transfers will be handled.

Step 3: Value Both Businesses Before Calculating Ownership

Now we get to Craig's original question.

How do you determine the value of the shares used in a merger?

The first step is to establish the value of both businesses.

You can't calculate a reasonable ownership split until you understand what each party is contributing.

Example: Merging a $5 Million Business With a $2.5 Million Business

Imagine Craig owns a business worth $5 million.

Another owner has a business worth $2.5 million.

They decide to merge.

Assuming these are comparable equity values, with no other adjustments, the combined value would be:

BusinessContributed value
Craig's company$5,000,000
Other owner's company$2,500,000
Combined value$7,500,000

Now calculate each owner's proportion of the total.

Craig contributes $5 million out of $7.5 million.

That represents approximately 66.67%.

The other owner contributes $2.5 million out of $7.5 million.

That represents approximately 33.33%.

<escape>Ownership after the merger:</escape>

  • Craig: 66.67%

  • Other owner: 33.33%

This is the basic principle behind determining the ownership split.

Each person receives shares based on the relative value of their contribution.

Why Both Parties Must Agree on the Valuations

This calculation only works if both owners agree on the values.

If Craig believes his company is worth $5 million but the other owner believes it's worth $3 million, the ownership discussion becomes more complicated.

The same problem occurs if the parties disagree about the value of the second company.

Both businesses need to be evaluated using appropriate valuation methods and assumptions.

The owners should also understand whether they're comparing equity values or enterprise values and how debt, excess cash, and working capital affect the calculation.

A merger based on shares requires agreement on the economic value each owner contributes.

Step 4: Determine How Many Shares to Issue

Once the relative values are established, the next question is how to implement the ownership arrangement.

Let's return to Craig's example.

His company is worth $5 million.

The other company is worth $2.5 million.

And Craig currently owns 100 shares of his company.

The 100-Share Example

Suppose Craig's company issues 50 new shares to the other business owner in exchange for the agreed business assets.

The total number of shares becomes 150.

Craig continues holding his original 100 shares.

The other owner receives 50 shares.

ShareholderShares ownedOwnership percentage
Craig10066.67%
Other owner5033.33%
Total150100%

This produces the same ownership percentages as the relative business valuations.

Why the Number of Shares Matters Less Than the Percentage

Craig doesn't necessarily need to issue exactly 50 shares.

The important thing is the ownership proportion.

For example, a different share structure could produce the same economic split.

But in this illustration, issuing 50 new shares is a simple way to demonstrate the mechanics.

The other owner receives one-third of the combined company because they're contributing one-third of its agreed value.

This is a simplified example; actual share rights, capital structures, liabilities, and transaction terms can change the outcome.

Step 5: Choose the Legal Structure of the Merger

Calculating the ownership split is relatively straightforward once the valuations are agreed upon.

Implementing the merger can be much more complicated.

There are several possible structures.

And the best choice depends on the jurisdiction, existing legal entities, tax consequences, and personal circumstances of the owners.

Option 1: One Company Acquires the Other Company's Assets Using Shares

This is the arrangement Craig appeared to be considering.

His company would acquire the assets of the other business.

Instead of paying cash, Craig's company would issue new shares to the other owner.

The seller effectively exchanges their business assets for an ownership interest in Craig's company.

Option 2: Create a New Company

Another possibility is establishing an entirely new legal entity.

That new company could acquire the businesses or assets contributed by both owners.

The owners would receive shares in the new company based on their agreed contributions.

This may provide a fresh legal structure for the combined operation.

Option 3: Legally Amalgamate the Existing Corporations

Depending on the jurisdiction, the owners may be able to combine the existing corporations through a formal statutory merger or amalgamation.

This can involve specific legal procedures and approvals.

Option 4: Maintain Separate Companies With Cross-Ownership

Another approach is to keep the two businesses legally separate while creating shared ownership.

Each owner could receive shares in the other's company.

This arrangement may be particularly relevant when businesses operate in different countries.

The companies remain separate legal entities but become economically connected through their ownership interests.

Why You Need a Qualified Accountant and Lawyer

I would strongly recommend involving a qualified accountant early in the process.

Different structures can create very different tax consequences.

For example, transferring depreciated assets may trigger taxable gains or depreciation recapture, depending on the jurisdiction and applicable rules.

The owners' other investments and financial circumstances may also influence the most appropriate structure.

Once the tax and accounting considerations are understood, legal advisers can help implement the arrangement.

This is not something I would recommend attempting without professional guidance.

Can Two Businesses in Different Countries Merge?

Yes, businesses in different countries can establish ownership arrangements that allow them to work together.

But the structure may be more complicated because of different legal and tax systems.

Example: A U.S. Company and a Canadian Company

Imagine an American manufacturer and a Canadian manufacturer operating in similar industries.

They want to coordinate production in response to trade barriers.

The American company could manufacture products for the U.S. market.

The Canadian company could manufacture products for the Canadian market.

The two businesses might exchange ownership interests.

Each company would remain legally separate, but both owners would have an economic interest in the other's operations.

Cross-Ownership Arrangements

This type of arrangement has similarities to cross-shareholding relationships found in some large industrial networks.

For example, a supplier making substantial investments to serve a major customer may want a long-term commercial relationship.

Cross-ownership can be one way to align their economic interests.

However, cross-ownership alone doesn't necessarily constitute a statutory merger. The legal classification depends on the arrangement and jurisdiction.

The broader lesson is that combining economic interests doesn't always require eliminating one of the existing companies.

Step 6: Review Licensing, Contracts, and Regulatory Requirements

One of the most easily overlooked merger risks involves licenses and contracts.

A business may operate successfully under its existing legal entity.

But changing that entity could trigger unexpected consequences.

What Happens to Business Licenses?

Some industries require specialized licenses or permits.

Those licenses may be attached to individuals, legal entities, or specific business locations.

If the company changes ownership or legal structure, you need to determine whether the licenses remain valid.

In some cases, additional applications or approvals may be required.

Government Contracts Can Be Particularly Sensitive

Imagine a janitorial company has a contract to clean a county courthouse.

The contract may be tied to the company's existing legal identity and registration details.

If the merger creates a new entity, the contract could require consent, reassignment, or other action.

Depending on the terms, the business might even need to compete for the contract again.

That could create a serious problem if the contract represents a significant portion of revenue.

Review Agreements Before the Merger

Before finalizing the transaction, investigate whether important agreements contain restrictions triggered by ownership changes or transfers.

This may include customer contracts, supplier agreements, leases, financing arrangements, and government contracts.

You want to identify these issues before committing to a structure that creates avoidable problems.

Step 7: Plan the Integration of Both Businesses

After the merger is structured, the next major challenge is integration.

Each business probably has its own way of operating.

It may use different software.

It may have different procedures.

And employees may be accustomed to different management practices.

The owners need to determine how the combined business will function.

Decide Which Operating Systems to Keep

Sometimes the acquiring business has better systems.

Other times, the company being acquired has developed more efficient procedures.

You shouldn't automatically assume that the larger company has the better approach.

Instead, compare the systems and determine which ones make the most sense for the combined operation.

The Customer Relationship Management Problem

Imagine both companies use different customer relationship management systems.

One uses a modern CRM.

The other uses an older database.

You decide to move all customers into one system.

That sounds straightforward.

But what happens to their historical records?

Can the data be transferred?

Will employees still be able to see previous service requests, purchases, or communications?

These details matter.

My Experience With a Furnace Repair Company

I recently called a furnace repair company that had provided service to me several years earlier.

The person answering the phone asked whether I'd used the company before.

I explained that I had.

She told me they no longer had access to their old system because the computer had finally stopped working.

I realized she'd apparently been dealing with two separate systems for years.

One contained older customer information.

The other contained newer records.

That meant employees had to search multiple databases depending on when the customer first used the business.

And eventually, the old records became inaccessible.

That's exactly the kind of operational problem you want to avoid when merging companies.

Integration Should Begin Before Closing

Before the merger is completed, determine how customer information will be transferred.

Review accounting systems.

Compare payroll processes.

Consider supplier management.

And establish a plan for transitioning employees and customers.

You may not be able to eliminate every problem.

But planning can reduce disruption.

Step 8: Manage Employees, Customers, and Corporate Culture

Even if the financial and legal structure makes sense, the merger can still struggle because of people.

Corporate culture is a major consideration.

Two businesses may operate in the same industry but have very different management styles.

One company might have a highly structured organization.

The other might allow employees considerable independence.

Combining those cultures can create tension.

Communicate With Employees

Employees need to understand what the merger means for them.

Will their responsibilities change?

Will they report to different managers?

Will their compensation or benefits change?

And what will happen to the systems they currently use?

Uncertainty can create anxiety and reduce productivity.

Clear communication can help employees understand the transition.

Communicate With Customers and Suppliers

Customers may also have concerns.

Will their existing agreements remain in place?

Will service quality change?

Will they continue working with the same employees?

Suppliers may need updated billing information, credit arrangements, or contractual documentation.

These issues should be addressed as part of the integration plan.

Don't Underestimate Personality Differences

Small businesses are often strongly influenced by their owners' personalities.

That makes compatibility particularly important.

Two owners may agree that a merger creates financial benefits.

But if they have fundamentally different ideas about management, spending, employees, or customer service, the relationship may become difficult.

As I emphasized in the video:

"Can you get along with the other person is really going to be critical." —David C. Barnett

That's why I would investigate personal compatibility as carefully as the financial aspects of the merger.

Can a Merger Help a Business Owner Retire?

Here's an interesting possibility.

A merger doesn't necessarily require both owners to remain actively involved in managing the combined business.

One owner might continue operating the company.

The other could become a passive shareholder.

Example: A Retiring Owner Merges With a Younger Operator

Imagine Craig is an experienced business owner who wants to grow.

He identifies another company in his industry.

The owner of that company is approaching retirement.

Instead of selling the business for cash, the retiring owner agrees to contribute it to the combined operation in exchange for shares.

Craig assumes responsibility for managing the larger business.

The retiring owner keeps an ownership interest but no longer needs to work in day-to-day operations.

If the combined company generates distributable profits, the retiring owner may receive dividends or other distributions according to the agreed structure.

Why This Can Be Attractive

The retiring owner doesn't necessarily need to sell the business outright.

They may continue participating in the company's future financial success.

Meanwhile, the active owner gains a larger operation without necessarily paying the entire acquisition price in cash.

But this arrangement creates ongoing investment risk.

The retiring owner is relying on the future success of the combined company.

And distributions are not guaranteed.

That's why the experience and track record of the active operator become particularly important.

How a Merger Relates to Seller Equity Rollover

If you've researched business acquisitions, you've probably encountered the term equity rollover.

This is when a seller retains an ownership interest in the business after a transaction.

For example, an acquirer might purchase a company but offer the seller shares in the combined business as part of the consideration.

The seller receives some cash and retains some equity.

What Happens When the Entire Price Is Paid in Shares?

In Craig's proposed arrangement, the other owner could receive shares instead of cash for the agreed contribution.

Economically, this resembles a transaction where the seller rolls the entire agreed consideration into equity.

The seller becomes a shareholder in the larger company.

The buyer gains control of the contributed business assets or operations, depending on the structure.

And both parties share in the combined company's future performance.

Why a Strong Track Record Helps

This strategy may be particularly attractive for business owners who have demonstrated that they can operate companies successfully.

Imagine you've operated a profitable business for ten years.

You have financial statements showing consistent performance.

You have an established management team.

And you can demonstrate that the company functions effectively.

That history may give another owner more confidence about exchanging their business for shares in your company.

Without that track record, persuading someone to accept shares instead of cash may be more difficult.

The Biggest Risks of Merging Two Small Businesses

A merger can create opportunities, but it also introduces risks.

Here's a summary of the major issues I would investigate.

RiskWhy it mattersWhat to investigate
Owner incompatibilityDisagreements can disrupt operationsManagement styles, responsibilities, decision-making
Incorrect valuationsOne owner may receive an unfair ownership percentageIndependent valuations and consistent assumptions
Undisclosed liabilitiesFinancial problems may carry into the combined businessFinancial, legal, and tax due diligence
Tax consequencesAsset transfers may trigger unexpected taxesQualified accounting and tax advice
Licensing problemsLegal changes may affect the right to operateLicenses, permits, and regulatory approvals
Contract restrictionsImportant agreements may not transfer automaticallyAssignment and change-of-control provisions
Software incompatibilityPoor integration can disrupt customer serviceCRM, accounting, payroll, and data migration
Cultural differencesEmployees may resist new management practicesCommunication and change management
Passive ownership riskRetiring owners may depend on future distributionsGovernance, reporting, dividend policies, and exit provisions

The objective isn't to eliminate every possible risk.

It's to understand the risks before committing to the transaction.

Small Business Merger Checklist

If you're considering combining your company with another business, I recommend working through the following questions.

  1. Why do the two businesses want to merge?

  2. What strategic advantages will the combined company have?

  3. Can the owners work together effectively?

  4. Who will manage the business after the merger?

  5. What responsibilities will each owner have?

  6. Have both parties completed due diligence?

  7. What is each business worth?

  8. How will the ownership percentages be calculated?

  9. Will the transaction involve new shares, a new entity, an amalgamation, or cross-ownership?

  10. What are the tax consequences?

  11. Will licenses, contracts, or financing arrangements be affected?

  12. How will operating systems and customer records be integrated?

  13. How will employees, customers, and suppliers be informed?

  14. Will either owner become a passive shareholder?

  15. What happens if the owners disagree or one wants to exit?

These questions provide a useful starting point for planning the transaction.

You'll still need professional legal and accounting advice.

But understanding the issues can help you have more productive conversations with your advisers.

Final Thoughts: A Successful Merger Requires More Than a Fair Share Price

Merging two small businesses can be an effective way to grow, expand into new markets, combine complementary services, or create a retirement arrangement for an existing owner.

But the process involves much more than deciding how many shares to issue.

You need to establish a strategic reason for combining the companies.

Both parties must complete due diligence.

You need to value the businesses using appropriate methods.

And the owners must agree on the legal structure and their respective responsibilities.

Then comes the work of integrating operations, systems, employees, customers, and corporate cultures.

In my view, the relationship between the owners is especially important.

Small businesses are often heavily influenced by the people running them.

If those people can't work together, even a financially attractive merger may become difficult.

The best merger is one where both owners understand what they're contributing, agree on how the combined company will operate, and have a realistic plan for creating value together.

Learn More About Business Acquisitions, Valuation, and Management

If you're considering acquiring or merging with another business, my Business Buyer Advantage programs can help you understand valuation, due diligence, deal structuring, and acquisition risks.

Explore Business Buyer Advantage

If you're working on developing operating systems, management responsibilities, and a business that can function without your constant involvement, explore my Build a Business That People Will Want to Buy program.

Explore Easy Small Biz Systems

Monday, February 24, 2025

LIVE- Henry Lopez Strategic Plans for Small Business

What do you plan to get done this year?

Returning Livestream guest- Henry Lopez

I’m happy to have Henry join me on a live broadcast. He has many years of small business experience including several startups and exits. Tune in and as we’ll be discussing how small businesses can create a realistic strategic plan. He’s actually got a tool you can download to make it easier. This is a ‘must see event’ for business owners or people who plan to be there one day. Find Henry on Linkedin here: https://www.linkedin.com/in/henry-lopez-9758524/ or his podcast here: https://www.thehowofbusiness.com/


Saturday, February 22, 2025

When Should You Hire Your First Employee?

 One of the biggest challenges for small business owners is determining when to hire their first employee. As a startup owner, you may be managing everything on your own, but there comes a point when your workload becomes overwhelming. How do you know if it’s the right time to expand your team? This guide will help you decide when to take the leap and make your first hire. https://youtu.be/qZ_16gRcO00 



Step 1: Track How You Spend Your Time

Before making any hiring decisions, start by keeping a detailed time log. Track everything you do throughout the day, from answering emails and meeting clients to completing technical work. By documenting your tasks, you’ll gain a clear understanding of where your time is being spent.

Step 2: Categorize Tasks by Value

Once you have a record of your workweek, evaluate each task based on the value it brings to your business. A simple way to categorize your tasks is:

  • $10/hour tasks – Basic admin work (e.g., answering phones, making copies, scheduling appointments).

  • $100/hour tasks – Skilled technical work or direct sales that generate revenue.

  • $1,000/hour tasks – High-value activities such as closing big deals or managing critical projects.

  • $10,000/hour tasks – Strategic decision-making that impacts long-term business growth.

Step 3: Identify Tasks to Delegate

Most small business owners spend too much time on $10 and $100/hour tasks—work that could easily be delegated to someone else. If these low-value activities are consuming a significant portion of your time, hiring an employee to handle them can be a smart investment.

By delegating these tasks, you can shift your focus to revenue-generating activities, business growth strategies, and customer relationships—all of which drive long-term success.

Step 4: Overcome the Fear of Hiring

Hiring your first employee is a big step, and it can feel like a financial risk. However, it’s important to view it as an investment. If bringing in help enables you to close more deals, improve operational efficiency, and boost profitability, then the benefits will far exceed the cost of their salary.

The Power of Leveraging Others

Successful businesses grow by leveraging the time and expertise of others. Hiring an employee isn’t just about lightening your workload—it’s about maximizing your impact. By focusing on high-value tasks and delegating routine work, you’ll be better positioned for long-term business success.

Conclusion & Next Steps

If you’re spending too much time on low-value tasks, it may be time to hire your first employee. The key is to track your time, identify which tasks to delegate, and focus on work that truly contributes to business growth.

For more insights on buying, selling, and building businesses as well as 7 FREE gifts, sign up for our email list at www.DavidCBarnettList.com 


Friday, February 21, 2025

Awesome Interview with The How of Business - How to start, run & grow a small business Podcast

 In this episode of The How of Business, Henry Lopez welcomes back David Barnett, a business consultant, author, and speaker specializing in buying and selling small businesses.

David shares his expert insights on the advantages of buying an existing business versus starting one, the common mistakes buyers make, and how to structure a business acquisition for success.

He also discusses his latest book, Buying vs. Starting a Business, and offers practical advice on evaluating business opportunities.

Wednesday, February 19, 2025

Trump Tariff Impact on Small Business Deals

 

How Trump Tariffs Affect Small Business Sales, Valuations & Acquisitions

What happens to the value of a small business when tariffs suddenly increase its costs, disrupt its supply chain, or threaten its customers?

And if you're planning to buy or sell a business, how should you account for those risks when negotiating a deal?

These are important questions because tariffs don't just affect large manufacturers and international corporations.

They can also affect small businesses that have never imported or exported a single product.

A local restaurant, construction contractor, repair company, or service provider could experience financial consequences simply because its customers work for companies involved in international trade.

And when those effects begin showing up in financial statements, they can change how buyers, sellers, and lenders evaluate business acquisitions.

I've spent years discussing buying, selling, financing, and managing small and medium-sized businesses while controlling risk.

Today, I want to examine how tariffs can affect small business deals, why uncertainty matters so much, and what business owners should consider before making major financial decisions.


utomobile manufacturers maintained separate production facilities for the Canadian and American markets.

Cars sold in Canada were largely manufactured in Canada.

Cars sold in the United States were largely manufactured in the United States.

But maintaining separate production systems created inefficiencies.

The 1965 Auto Pact

In 1965, Canada and the United States signed the Automotive Products Trade Agreement, commonly known as the Auto Pact.

The agreement helped establish a more integrated automobile manufacturing industry.

Instead of requiring every factory to manufacture a wide variety of models for its domestic market, companies could specialize.

One plant might manufacture certain models for customers in both countries.

Another plant could produce different models.

The result was a more integrated production system.

From Free Trade to USMCA

North American trade integration continued through several major agreements.

  • 1988: Canada and the United States signed a bilateral free trade agreement, which took effect in 1989.

  • 1994: The North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) took effect, including Mexico.

  • 2020: The United States–Mexico–Canada Agreement (USMCA) replaced NAFTA.

Over time, businesses made investment decisions based on these trading relationships.

Factories were built in locations where production made the most economic sense.

Supply chains were organized across borders.

And companies developed systems that depended on goods moving relatively efficiently between countries.

This is why broad tariffs can create such significant disruption.

They introduce new costs into arrangements that were developed under different economic assumptions.

How Tariffs Increase Costs: The Toilet Paper Example

I live in Moncton, New Brunswick.

Our region has a significant forest products industry.

Wood processing generates materials such as sawdust and wood chips, which can be used to produce pulp.

That pulp can then be used to manufacture products such as toilet paper.

In the recording, I used an example involving toilet paper factories in New Brunswick and Pennsylvania.

It demonstrates how trade patterns can develop around geography and transportation costs.

Why New Brunswick Exports Toilet Paper to the United States

Consider the state of Maine.

It's geographically close to New Brunswick.

If a toilet paper manufacturer in New Brunswick can supply Maine retailers more efficiently than a factory located much farther away, buying from New Brunswick makes economic sense.

Meanwhile, parts of Ontario may be closer to American manufacturing facilities in Pennsylvania.

As a result, Ontario retailers might purchase products manufactured in the United States.

So one Canadian province exports toilet paper while another imports it.

That might sound strange until you look at the geography.

The purchasing decisions are based on efficiency.

What Happens When a 25% Tariff Is Introduced?

Now imagine a hypothetical 25% tariff applies to toilet paper imported from New Brunswick into the United States.

A retailer in Maine faces a decision.

Should it continue buying from New Brunswick and pay the tariff?

Or should it purchase toilet paper from a more distant American factory and pay additional transportation costs?

Either option could increase costs.

If the retailer continues purchasing the imported product and the entire tariff cost is passed through to consumers, the price increase could look like this:

ItemAmount
Original purchase cost$50.00
Hypothetical tariff25%
Additional cost$12.50
New cost$62.50

This simplified example assumes the tariff is fully passed through, with no offsetting changes in margins, sourcing, or other costs.

The point is that tariffs can interfere with established low-cost supply arrangements.

Why Consumers May Ultimately Pay More

A tariff is generally collected from the importer under the applicable customs rules.

But the economic burden may be distributed among importers, suppliers, retailers, and consumers.

Some businesses may absorb part of the increase.

Others may negotiate lower supplier prices.

And many will attempt to pass additional costs to their customers.

The outcome depends on the market.

However, when tariffs increase the cost of obtaining goods, businesses must find a way to deal with that additional expense.

And that can create inflationary pressure.

The Three Ways Tariffs Affect Small Businesses

When evaluating the effects of tariffs, I think it's useful to divide the consequences into three categories.

These are direct impacts, derivative impacts, and indirect impacts.

Each one creates different risks.

1. Direct Impacts: Higher Import Costs and Export Challenges

Direct impacts affect businesses that purchase goods from other countries or sell products into foreign markets.

Imagine you're a small manufacturer that imports most of its raw materials.

If tariffs increase the cost of those materials, your production costs rise.

Now you have to decide what to do.

The Aluminum Manufacturer Example

In the video, I discussed a social media post from a small American manufacturer named Derek Turner.

According to the post, approximately 80% of his cost of goods sold consisted of imported aluminum components.

He was concerned about a 25% tariff affecting those components.

That's a significant problem for a manufacturer.

If a large portion of your costs suddenly increases, your gross profit margin can decline dramatically.

What Can the Business Owner Do?

There are several possible responses.

The business could raise its selling prices.

It might look for alternative suppliers.

It could negotiate with existing suppliers.

Or it could attempt to redesign its products to use different materials.

But none of these solutions is necessarily easy.

Raising prices may reduce customer demand.

Changing suppliers can create quality or reliability concerns.

And redesigning products may require additional investment.

Exporters Face the Opposite Problem

Now consider the foreign company supplying those aluminum components.

If its American customers face higher costs, they may reduce their orders.

The exporter could lose revenue even though it isn't the company directly paying the import tariff.

That's how tariffs can affect both sides of an international transaction.

2. Derivative Impacts: Your Customers May Be Affected

Derivative impacts occur when your business serves customers that are directly affected by tariffs.

You might not import or export anything yourself.

But your customers do.

And if their financial position deteriorates, your business may suffer.

Example: An Industrial Electrical Contractor

Imagine you operate an electrical contracting company in Pennsylvania.

One of your largest customers is a paper mill.

You maintain electrical systems, repair equipment, and perform installation work.

Now suppose that mill exports a significant portion of its production to Canada.

If retaliatory tariffs reduce demand for its products, the mill may respond by reducing expenses.

It could postpone equipment upgrades.

It might cancel maintenance projects.

And it may reduce spending on outside contractors.

Suddenly, your electrical contracting business has less work.

Accounts Receivable Can Become a Problem

There's another risk.

Suppose the mill begins experiencing cash flow problems.

Previously, it paid your invoices within 30 days.

Now payments are taking 45 days.

Then 60 days.

Eventually, you may face the possibility of not collecting the money at all.

This is why small business owners need to understand the financial condition of their customers.

A tariff problem affecting another company can quickly become a cash flow problem for you.

Review Your Customer Portfolio

If you operate a business-to-business company, examine your customer list.

Which customers depend heavily on international trade?

Which ones import materials?

Which ones export finished products?

And which customers could experience financial difficulty if their costs increase or sales decline?

This analysis can help you identify risks before they become obvious in your own financial statements.

3. Indirect Impacts: The Local Economy Can Affect Your Business

Indirect impacts occur when tariffs affect the broader economy surrounding your business.

This can be particularly important in communities that depend on major industrial employers.

Example: A Swimming Pool Contractor in Michigan

Imagine you operate a swimming pool construction company in Michigan.

Your customers are homeowners.

You don't export swimming pools.

And you may purchase most of your materials domestically.

At first glance, international tariffs might not seem especially relevant.

But what if a large percentage of your customers work in automobile manufacturing?

The North American automobile industry has highly integrated supply chains.

Components may cross international borders multiple times during production.

If trade restrictions disrupt production, employers may reduce hours, postpone hiring, or temporarily suspend operations.

How That Affects Consumer Spending

A homeowner concerned about job security may decide not to install a swimming pool.

Another customer might postpone a home renovation.

Families may reduce spending on restaurants, entertainment, and other discretionary purchases.

So your business can experience declining demand even though it has no direct involvement in international trade.

Why Local Economic Research Matters

This is particularly important when evaluating a business acquisition.

If you're buying a local service business, investigate the community's major employers.

Where do customers earn their money?

Which industries support the local economy?

And how exposed are those industries to international trade?

You may discover that a seemingly stable local business depends indirectly on a handful of large employers.

Why Tariff Uncertainty Can Be as Damaging as the Tariffs Themselves

One of the biggest problems with changing trade policies is uncertainty.

Business owners make decisions based on expectations about the future.

They invest in equipment.

They hire employees.

They expand facilities.

And they purchase other businesses.

Those decisions often require years to generate an acceptable return.

But when the rules can change unexpectedly, business owners become more cautious.

As I explained in the video:

"Business thrives on predictability." —David C. Barnett

Why Businesses Delay Investment

Imagine you're considering a $2 million manufacturing expansion.

You expect the investment to increase production capacity and generate additional profits over the next eight years.

But the profitability of that investment depends on your ability to sell products across an international border.

If you don't know what tariffs will apply next year, you may decide to postpone the project.

That decision might be reasonable from your perspective.

But it also affects the businesses that would have supplied construction services, equipment, and materials for the expansion.

Why Cash Becomes More Valuable During Uncertainty

When businesses are uncertain about future conditions, they often preserve cash.

They postpone unnecessary expenditures.

They delay hiring.

And they avoid committing to investments that could become difficult to reverse.

I saw similar behavior during the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Many businesses reduced spending because they didn't know what would happen next.

That same caution can appear when trade policy becomes unpredictable.

Can Small Businesses Adapt to Tariffs?

Yes, but adapting can be expensive.

Businesses have several potential options.

The right approach depends on their industry, customers, suppliers, and financial resources.

Find New Customers in Different Markets

A Canadian manufacturer that previously sold heavily into the United States might explore customers elsewhere in Canada.

It could also investigate European or other international markets.

However, entering new markets takes time.

You may need new distribution relationships, marketing efforts, and regulatory approvals.

Find Alternative Suppliers

If imported materials become more expensive, a business might look for domestic suppliers.

But those suppliers may not have sufficient capacity.

Their prices may already be higher.

And changing suppliers could create new logistical or quality-control problems.

Move Production to Another Country

Another option is relocating production.

For example, a Canadian manufacturer could establish operations in the United States to serve American customers.

But relocating production requires investment.

The company may need facilities, equipment, employees, and new supplier relationships.

Those costs eventually need to be recovered.

Use Local Subcontractors

Instead of relocating the entire business, a company could subcontract production to a manufacturer in the destination market.

A Canadian company selling to American customers might arrange for an American manufacturer to produce the goods locally.

This could reduce exposure to certain cross-border tariffs, depending on the applicable rules and sourcing arrangements.

However, it introduces new challenges involving quality control, supplier management, and production oversight.

Acquire a Business in Another Country

A company could also purchase an existing manufacturer in the country where it wants to sell.

That acquisition might provide local production capacity.

But it creates a new set of acquisition and integration risks.

And the buyer must consider whether the additional operating complexity is justified.

Why Moving Production Can Reduce Efficiency

Let's consider a manufacturer producing 1,000 units annually.

Before tariffs, it operates one factory.

That factory produces all 1,000 units efficiently.

Now suppose tariffs encourage the company to manufacture 20% of its products in another country.

The company may need to manage two production facilities.

That could mean additional accounting systems, payroll administration, suppliers, employees, and regulatory obligations.

But the company is still producing the same total number of units.

Its administrative costs may increase without any corresponding increase in sales.

The Hidden Cost of Duplicating Operations

When companies divide production across multiple facilities, they may lose some of the efficiencies associated with specialization.

They might need additional management.

They could face smaller production runs.

And they may need to maintain more inventory across different locations.

These costs can reduce profitability.

So even when a business successfully reorganizes its supply chain, it may still need to increase prices to maintain acceptable margins.

How Tariffs Affect Small Business Valuations

Now let's turn to the part of this discussion that's particularly important for business buyers and sellers.

How do tariffs affect the value of a business?

The answer depends on how they influence future earnings and risk.

A business is generally valued based on its ability to generate economic benefits for its owner.

If tariffs increase costs, reduce sales, or create uncertainty about future performance, buyers may become less willing to pay the same price.

Example: A Manufacturer Experiences a 30% Sales Decline

Imagine a manufacturing company has generated consistent growth for several years.

Its revenue has increased steadily.

Profit margins have remained healthy.

And the owner is preparing to sell.

Then tariffs affect its imported materials.

The company raises prices to compensate.

Customers reduce their orders.

And annual sales decline by 30%.

Profitability may fall even more sharply because the company still has fixed expenses.

Suddenly, the financial statements show a very different business.

Why Buyers Become Concerned

Before the tariffs, a buyer could examine several years of consistent performance.

That history provided some confidence about future earnings.

But now there's a major interruption.

The buyer must determine whether the decline is temporary or permanent.

Will customers return?

Will the company find alternative suppliers?

Will profit margins recover?

And how long will that recovery take?

Those questions introduce uncertainty.

And uncertainty can affect valuation.

Why Buyers May Discount a Business After Tariff Disruptions

A seller may argue that the business would still be highly profitable if tariffs hadn't been introduced.

That may be true.

But a buyer is purchasing the business under the conditions that exist at the time of the transaction.

The buyer must consider what the company is likely to earn in the future.

Historical Earnings May No Longer Be Reliable

Suppose a company generated $300,000 in annual earnings for several years.

Then tariff-related disruptions reduced earnings to $120,000.

The seller might argue that the business should still be valued based on its historical $300,000 performance.

But the buyer may question whether those earnings will return.

The buyer might not be willing to pay a price that assumes a full recovery.

Why a Lower Purchase Price Isn't the Only Solution

Sometimes buyers and sellers can structure transactions to share the uncertainty.

Rather than agreeing on one fixed price paid entirely at closing, they may use contingent payments.

This brings us to earnouts and seller financing.

How Earnouts Can Help Buyers and Sellers Manage Tariff Risk

An earnout is a transaction structure where part of the purchase price depends on the business achieving agreed financial results after closing.

For example, imagine a seller believes the company's earnings will recover once trade conditions stabilize.

The buyer isn't convinced.

Instead of ending negotiations, they could agree on a lower upfront payment with additional compensation if the business performs well.

Example: A Performance-Based Earnout

Suppose the parties agree to a hypothetical transaction with the following structure:

Payment componentAmount
Payment at closing$600,000
Additional payment if agreed performance targets are achievedUp to $200,000
Maximum total consideration$800,000

Illustrative figures only.

The seller receives $600,000 at closing.

If the company meets the agreed financial targets, the seller may receive up to another $200,000.

This gives the seller an opportunity to benefit from a recovery.

But it protects the buyer from paying the entire amount upfront for earnings that may not materialize.

Seller Financing Can Also Be Structured Around Performance

Another option is seller financing.

The seller agrees to receive part of the purchase price over time.

Depending on the agreement, some payment obligations may be linked to future sales or earnings.

However, these arrangements require careful legal and financial structuring.

The parties need clear definitions of performance, reporting obligations, payment conditions, and dispute-resolution procedures.

The goal is to allocate uncertainty between the buyer and seller in a way both parties can accept.

Why Trade Exposure Should Become Part of Acquisition Due Diligence

If you're buying a business that could be affected by tariffs, traditional due diligence may not be enough.

You still need to examine financial statements, customer concentration, supplier relationships, and operating systems.

But you should also investigate the company's exposure to international trade.

Investigate Customer and Supplier Geography

Start by identifying where the business's major suppliers and customers are located.

Does the company import materials?

Does it export products?

Do its customers rely on international markets?

And are any important suppliers located in countries affected by trade restrictions?

Understand the Company's Cost Structure

If the business imports goods, determine how much of its cost of goods sold is exposed to tariffs.

A company importing 5% of its materials may face a very different risk from one importing 80%.

You also need to understand whether the business can pass additional costs to customers.

Review the Local Economy

For consumer-facing businesses, examine the industries supporting local employment.

A restaurant in a community dominated by export-oriented manufacturers may have more tariff exposure than its own purchasing records suggest.

Assess Alternative Supply Arrangements

Could the business obtain materials from different suppliers?

Would switching suppliers increase costs?

Would it require new equipment or changes in production?

And how long would the transition take?

These questions can help you determine whether the business has realistic options if trade conditions change.

Tariff Risk Due Diligence Checklist

Due diligence areaQuestions to ask
Imported materialsWhat percentage of costs depends on imported goods?
Export revenueHow much revenue comes from foreign customers?
Customer exposureAre major customers vulnerable to tariffs?
Supplier concentrationCan alternative suppliers provide the same materials?
Gross profit marginsCan the business absorb additional costs?
Pricing powerCan higher costs be passed to customers?
Customer demandWill price increases reduce sales volumes?
Accounts receivableAre affected customers taking longer to pay?
Local employmentDoes the community depend on trade-exposed employers?
Capital requirementsWill the business need new facilities or equipment?
Historical performanceHave tariffs already interrupted earnings?
Recovery assumptionsWhat evidence supports the expected recovery?
FinancingWill lenders finance the acquisition under the proposed terms?
Deal structureCould an earnout or contingent seller note help manage risk?

The more exposed the company is to international trade, the more important these questions become.

What Tariffs Mean for Business Sellers

If you're planning to sell a business, tariff-related disruptions can create difficult valuation conversations.

Buyers may become more cautious.

Lenders may require additional evidence of stable cash flow.

And a decline in earnings can make the company harder to value.

You May Need to Rebuild Your Financial Track Record

Suppose your company experiences a major decline because of trade disruptions.

Even if the business eventually recovers, prospective buyers may want to see evidence that the recovery is sustainable.

That could mean operating the company for another couple of years before selling.

The objective is to establish a new period of consistent financial performance.

Buyers Won't Necessarily Pay for an Expected Recovery

You might believe tariffs will eventually disappear.

You may expect customers to return.

And you could be confident that earnings will recover.

But buyers may not be willing to pay upfront for that expectation.

As I discussed in the video, buyers may prefer an earnout or another structure that compensates the seller if the recovery actually occurs.

Prepare to Explain Your Trade Exposure

If your company depends on international trade, be ready to explain how tariffs affect its operations.

Show buyers what percentage of revenue and expenses is exposed.

Explain what changes you've already made.

And provide evidence supporting your future earnings expectations.

The more clearly you can demonstrate the risks and your response to them, the easier it may be for buyers to evaluate the opportunity.

What Tariffs Mean for Business Buyers

If you're planning to acquire a business, tariffs don't necessarily mean you should stop looking.

There may still be attractive opportunities.

But you need to evaluate them carefully.

Don't Assume Historical Performance Will Continue

A company may have generated stable profits for ten years.

But if its economic environment has changed, those historical results may no longer provide a reliable forecast.

You need to understand the company's future earnings potential under different trade conditions.

Consider Downside Scenarios

What happens if imported material costs increase?

What if export sales decline?

What if major customers reduce spending?

And what happens if the business needs additional working capital to survive?

Testing these scenarios can help you determine whether the acquisition remains financially viable.

Structure the Transaction Around Risk

If the business faces significant uncertainty, you may want to negotiate contingent payments or other protections.

The objective is to avoid paying for financial performance that may not continue.

But remember that a lower purchase price doesn't automatically make a risky business a good acquisition.

The business still needs a credible path to sustainable cash flow.

Why Lenders May Become More Cautious

Business acquisition financing depends heavily on the lender's confidence that the company can generate enough cash flow to repay its debt.

If tariffs threaten that cash flow, lenders may become more conservative.

They might examine customer concentration more closely.

They may question earnings forecasts.

Or they could require additional equity or collateral.

In the recording, I suggested that lenders would likely begin paying more attention to trade exposure when evaluating acquisitions.

That was my expectation at the time, not a verified statement about every lender's underwriting policies.

For buyers, the practical lesson is to discuss tariff exposure with potential lenders early.

You don't want to spend months negotiating a transaction only to discover that financing is unavailable under the proposed structure.

Can Tariff Uncertainty Affect the Entire M&A Market?

Yes.

Even businesses that aren't immediately affected by tariffs can experience consequences when buyers and investors become uncertain about the future.

A company considering a major acquisition may decide to wait.

A manufacturer planning a new facility might postpone construction.

And a business owner considering retirement may delay selling until financial conditions become more predictable.

Why Long-Term Investment Decisions Become Difficult

Imagine a European manufacturer wants to expand into North America.

Before trade uncertainty, it might evaluate where a single factory could most efficiently serve customers across Canada, the United States, and Mexico.

But if future trade barriers are unpredictable, choosing the factory's location becomes more complicated.

The company may decide to postpone the investment.

That decision affects construction contractors, equipment suppliers, engineering firms, and other businesses that would have participated in the project.

Uncertainty Can Have Lasting Effects

Even if tariffs are later reduced or removed, companies may remember how quickly the trading environment changed.

That experience can influence future investment decisions.

Businesses may place greater value on flexibility.

They might diversify production locations.

Or they may require higher expected returns before committing to projects exposed to international trade.

These responses can affect small businesses throughout the economy.

Why Small Business Ownership Always Involves Risk

I don't want this discussion to suggest that small businesses are suddenly too risky to buy.

Small business ownership has always involved uncertainty.

Economic conditions change.

Customers leave.

Competitors enter the market.

Regulations evolve.

And unexpected events can disrupt even well-established companies.

As I said in the video:

"Small businesses are the riskiest asset class there is to invest in." —David C. Barnett

The point isn't that you should avoid business ownership.

It's that you need to understand the risks you're accepting.

Cash Gives You More Options

One lesson I've emphasized repeatedly is the importance of maintaining financial flexibility.

A business with adequate cash reserves may be better positioned to survive a temporary decline.

It may have more time to find new suppliers or customers.

And it may be able to make decisions without immediately facing a liquidity crisis.

As I explained:

"Money is always the thing that gives you more options." —David C. Barnett

This is especially important when the future is uncertain.

Final Thoughts: Tariffs Change the Risks Buyers and Sellers Need to Evaluate

Tariffs can affect small businesses in ways that aren't immediately obvious.

They may increase the cost of imported materials.

They can reduce demand for exported products.

They may create cash flow problems for customers and suppliers.

And they can weaken local economies that depend on international trade.

For business buyers, this means trade exposure should become part of the due diligence process whenever it's relevant.

You need to understand where customers and suppliers are located, how the business responds to higher costs, and whether its historical earnings remain sustainable.

For sellers, tariffs may create difficult valuation discussions.

If the company's earnings have been disrupted, buyers may want evidence of recovery or transaction structures that reduce their exposure to uncertainty.

And for lenders, the company's ability to generate reliable future cash flow remains essential.

I believe there will continue to be opportunities to buy and sell good businesses.

But successful transactions require realistic expectations and careful evaluation of the risks.

The important question isn't simply whether tariffs will increase or decrease. It's whether the business you're buying or selling can remain profitable under the economic conditions it may face.

Learn More About Buying, Selling, and Valuing Small Businesses

If you're considering buying a business and want to understand how economic uncertainty, valuation, financing, and due diligence affect an acquisition, my Business Buyer Advantage programs can help.

I offer online training, group coaching, and consulting services designed to help buyers evaluate opportunities and manage acquisition risk.

Explore Business Buyer Advantage

For more articles, videos, books, and resources about buying, selling, financing, and managing small and medium-sized businesses, visit my website.

Monday, February 17, 2025

PREMIERE- Michael Jacobson Disrupting the flower market

 


Disrupting the Flower Retail Market- Interview Premiere

New Premiere guest- Michael Jacobson- French Florist

I’m happy to have Michael join me on a live broadcast.

He’s got a story to tell you about how he came to own a flower shop and how he grew it to several locations before heading down the franchise path.

AND- why flower retail is so ripe for innovation and disruption.

Tune in and as we’ll be discussing the retail flower industry and why it might be a great opportunity for someone.

This is a ‘must see event’ for people who like technology, marketing and are ‘industry agnostic.’

Set yourself a reminder on YouTube here: https://youtu.be/0L0OwsTOBCY 

The interview plays live Monday February 17, 2025 at 1PM Atlantic Time and 12 Noon Eastern Time

See you there!

David C Barnett


Saturday, February 15, 2025

Selling Your Business to an Employee: Is It a Smart Move?

 When it’s time to sell your small business, one of the biggest questions is whether selling to a long-time employee is a good idea. At first glance, it makes sense—they already understand the business, know the customers, and are familiar with daily operations. However, the reality is more complex. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ODZF3gTeETc 

In this blog, we’ll explore the pros and cons of selling your business to an employee and discuss better alternatives to ensure a successful transition.

The Difference Between Small and Mid-Sized Businesses

In larger businesses with structured management, employees often have clear roles, make decisions, and manage teams. These individuals may have the skills and mindset needed to transition into ownership.

However, in most small businesses, the owner retains control over all critical decisions. Employees, even those with managerial titles, may primarily focus on completing tasks rather than developing strategic vision or taking full responsibility. This lack of entrepreneurial experience can make it difficult for them to succeed as business owners.

The Risks of Selling to an Employee

From experience, I’ve seen multiple cases where business owners sold to long-time employees who later struggled and failed. The key issue? These employees lacked the core traits of a successful entrepreneur, including:

  • Decision-Making Ability – Business owners must make high-stakes decisions regularly.

  • Responsibility & Stress Management – The role comes with financial and operational pressures.

  • Ambition & Drive – Successful entrepreneurs have a strong desire to achieve and grow.

Many employees thrive under direction but struggle when placed in the role of an owner, where they must drive the business forward.

A Better Alternative: Consider Past Employees

Instead of selling to a current employee who may lack entrepreneurial ambition, consider reaching out to past employees who left the company for greater opportunities. These individuals already know the business but demonstrated ambition by seeking new challenges.

A former employee who moved on, gained more experience, and built financial stability may now be in a position where buying your business is an attractive opportunity.

Finding the Right Buyer for Your Business

If you’re considering selling, take the time to evaluate potential buyers beyond just convenience. Selling to an unprepared buyer can lead to failure, impacting your legacy and the long-term success of the business. Instead, look for individuals with a strong entrepreneurial mindset, whether they are former employees, industry professionals, or external buyers.

Ready to Sell? Get Expert Guidance

If you’re thinking about selling your business, visit my website for valuable resources, including “12 Things to Do Before You Consider Selling Your Business.” (FREE to email list subscribers) You’ll gain insights into preparing your business for sale, finding the right buyer, and ensuring a smooth transition.

Be sure to join my email list if you’re not on it already at https://www.DavidCBarnettList.com and receive 7 FREE gifts to help you on your journey!