10 Buyers for Every Business for Sale? Why Buying a Good Small Business Is So Competitive
For years, I've been telling people that there are roughly ten prospective buyers for every seller of a good small business.
That figure isn't based on a scientific census. There's no central registry where everyone interested in buying or selling a business signs up.
It's based on what I repeatedly observed when I operated my business brokerage.
Whenever we listed a profitable, transferable business with reliable cash flow, reasonable working hours, and a sensible asking price, buyer interest could be overwhelming.
Recently, I came across some interesting data that illustrates just how quickly interest in buying businesses has been growing.
And it reinforces something every prospective buyer needs to understand.
Finding a good business isn't enough. You need to be prepared to compete for it without overpaying or exposing yourself to unnecessary risk.
Are There Really 10 Buyers for Every Business Seller?
When I operated my brokerage between 2008 and 2011, I noticed a consistent pattern.
There were far more people interested in purchasing a profitable small business than there were owners offering attractive companies for sale.
I used to joke that if I listed a business generating more than $100,000 annually in seller's discretionary earnings, operating Monday through Friday during regular business hours, I could receive 40 inquiries on the first day.
That was a particularly attractive combination at the time.
Today, the earnings expectations would likely be higher, perhaps $200,000 or $250,000, but the principle remains the same.
A business with strong cash flow, predictable operations, and a reasonable asking price attracts attention.
And that attention creates competition.
New Reddit Data Shows Buyer Interest Growing Much Faster
I recently came across a post from Clinton Lee, an M&A professional in the United Kingdom who has previously appeared on my show.
Clinton helps business owners connect with appropriate M&A advisory firms based on factors such as industry, company size, and transaction requirements.
He also moderates several Reddit communities focused on business acquisitions, business sales, and business brokerage.
He shared some interesting observations about the growth of those communities.
According to his figures, the Reddit communities focused on selling businesses experienced approximately 30% growth over the previous year.
Meanwhile, the community focused on buying businesses grew approximately 300%.
That's a tenfold difference in their reported growth rates.
| Reddit community focus | Reported annual growth |
|---|---|
| Selling businesses | 30% |
| Buying businesses | 300% |
<text color="secondary" size="sm">Figures discussed in Clinton Lee's post, as presented in the video. These measure online community growth, not the actual number of business buyers and sellers.</text>
<Chart content={{"chartType":"bar","meta":{"title":"Buyer interest is growing faster","description":"Reported growth of Reddit communities focused on business transactions"},"xKey":"category","series":[{"dataKey":"growth","label":"Annual growth","valueSuffix":"%"}],"yAxisMin":0,"data":[{"category":"Selling businesses","growth":30},{"category":"Buying businesses","growth":300}]}}/>
Now, this doesn't prove that there are exactly ten buyers for every seller.
The figures measure growth in Reddit communities, not the number of qualified participants in the acquisition market.
But they illustrate something I've been observing for years.
Interest in buying businesses is increasing rapidly.
And that means more people may be competing for the same attractive opportunities.
Why Good Small Businesses Attract So Much Competition
Many first-time buyers enter the acquisition market believing the process will resemble purchasing a house.
They expect to browse listings, find a suitable business, submit an offer, arrange financing, and become the new owner.
Sometimes it really does work that way.
But attractive businesses rarely sit unnoticed.
Imagine a company with stable cash flow, clean financial records, loyal customers, reliable employees, and an owner who's realistic about the selling price.
That's exactly the kind of business many buyers want.
And when it appears on a popular business-for-sale website, other people will notice.
Some competing buyers may have more cash available.
Others may already operate similar businesses.
Some may have industry experience or established lending relationships.
And those advantages can make them appear more credible to brokers and sellers.
The competition isn't simply about finding the listing first.
It's about demonstrating that you're capable of completing the transaction.
Why Business Brokers Sometimes Ignore Buyer Inquiries
One of the most common complaints I hear from prospective buyers is that business brokers don't respond to their messages.
A buyer discovers an interesting listing, submits an inquiry, and hears nothing.
Naturally, that creates frustration.
But consider what might be happening on the broker's side.
A particularly attractive listing may generate dozens of inquiries almost immediately.
The broker must decide which prospective buyers deserve attention first.
Someone who sends a generic message saying they're interested may not stand out.
Meanwhile, another buyer might explain that they already own a business in the same industry, have financing relationships, understand the market, and can move quickly.
Which inquiry do you think is more likely to receive attention?
This is why preparation matters before you begin contacting brokers.
You need to communicate not only that you're interested but also why you're a credible buyer.
Paying the Highest Price Isn't the Best Way to Win
Some people respond to acquisition competition by suggesting that buyers simply need to offer more money.
I strongly disagree with that approach.
As I explained:
"Paying the highest price is the easiest way to turn a good opportunity into a bad deal" —David C. Barnett
Think about what happens when you increase the purchase price.
You may need to borrow more money.
That creates larger debt payments.
Those payments reduce the cash flow available for owner compensation, equipment replacement, working capital, and unexpected expenses.
The business itself hasn't necessarily become more profitable.
You've simply agreed to pay more for the same cash flow.
And if the company experiences a downturn, the additional debt can make the situation considerably more dangerous.
A good business purchased at the wrong price can become a terrible investment.
The goal isn't to outbid everyone.
The goal is to identify an attractive business and negotiate a transaction that makes financial sense.
Why Most Businesses Aren't Actually Good Acquisition Candidates
Here's another important reality.
Just because a business exists and generates revenue doesn't mean someone should pay money to acquire it.
Depending on the market and data source, estimates sometimes suggest that only about one in five businesses offered for sale actually change hands.
The remaining businesses may be withdrawn, remain unsold, close, or otherwise fail to complete an ownership transition.
The exact proportion varies, but the underlying problem is important.
Many small businesses are economically viable for their existing owners without being attractive investments for a new buyer.
For example, a company might generate enough income to support the current owner and pay its employees.
But after accounting for a purchase price, acquisition financing, reasonable owner compensation, and necessary reinvestment, the business may not generate enough cash flow to support a buyer.
Other companies have problems that make an ownership transition difficult.
They may have declining sales, unreliable financial records, outdated equipment, customer concentration, employee problems, or excessive dependence on the current owner.
Some sellers also have unrealistic expectations about what their companies are worth.
Others simply aren't emotionally ready to complete a sale.
This means the number of businesses genuinely worth acquiring may be much smaller than the number advertised for sale.
The Two Ways Unprepared Buyers Lose
In a competitive acquisition market, buyers who haven't prepared properly often experience one of two outcomes.
1. They Lose a Good Opportunity to a Better-Prepared Buyer
The first outcome is relatively straightforward.
A buyer finds an attractive company but doesn't understand the financing requirements.
They take too long to evaluate the financial statements.
They struggle to communicate with the broker or don't know how to structure a reasonable offer.
Meanwhile, another buyer moves forward.
That buyer may not necessarily be wealthier.
They may simply understand the acquisition process better.
They know what information to request, how to evaluate the opportunity, and how to demonstrate their ability to close.
As a result, they get the deal.
2. They Win the Deal by Overpaying and Ignoring the Risks
The second outcome is much more dangerous.
An inexperienced buyer becomes determined to win.
They offer too much money, overlook warning signs, or agree to unfavorable terms because they're afraid of losing the opportunity.
The transaction closes.
But the company doesn't generate enough cash flow to support the debt, owner compensation, and operating requirements.
The buyer may end up draining personal savings, damaging their credit, or becoming trapped in a stressful business that doesn't deliver the expected financial benefits.
This is why I believe proper acquisition education is so important.
Winning the bidding process isn't the same as making a successful investment.
What Separates Serious Business Buyers From Casual Searchers?
Serious buyers approach acquisitions with a clear understanding of what they're looking for and how transactions work.
They know how to evaluate financial statements.
They understand the differences between accounting profit, cash flow, and seller's discretionary earnings.
They consider working capital requirements, equipment replacement, inventory, goodwill, and financing.
They also understand the risks associated with the ownership transition.
A prepared buyer can investigate a business efficiently without rushing into a decision.
They know how to ask meaningful questions.
They understand what lenders need to see.
And they can communicate their acquisition strategy to brokers and sellers.
As I explained:
"Prepared means knowing when to keep going and when to walk away." —David C. Barnett
That's an important distinction.
Preparation doesn't mean becoming so enthusiastic that you're willing to complete any transaction.
It means developing the judgment necessary to recognize which opportunities deserve your attention.
How to Stand Out When Competing for a Business
If you're serious about acquiring a company, there are several things you can do to improve your position.
Define Your Ideal Acquisition
Start by identifying industries that match your experience and interests.
Consider the size of business you can realistically manage and finance.
Think about geographic requirements, management responsibilities, and the level of owner involvement you're prepared to accept.
A focused buyer can communicate more convincingly than someone who claims to be interested in almost any profitable business.
Understand Your Financing Capacity
Before submitting offers, investigate how much capital you have available and what financing options may be realistic.
Understand the equity contribution lenders are likely to require.
Know what types of businesses and financial characteristics lenders generally prefer.
You don't necessarily need a finalized financing package before searching.
But you should understand your financial limitations.
Learn to Analyze Cash Flow
Don't rely exclusively on the seller's asking price or advertised earnings.
Understand how much cash the business actually generates after normal operating expenses.
Determine what owner compensation is required.
Estimate debt service, working capital, and future capital expenditures.
Then consider what happens if performance declines.
Communicate Professionally With Brokers
When contacting a broker, explain why the business fits your acquisition criteria.
Briefly describe your relevant experience and financial preparedness.
Be responsive when reasonable information or documentation is requested.
You want the broker to recognize that you're capable of participating in a serious transaction.
Move Efficiently Without Sacrificing Due Diligence
Being prepared allows you to move quickly because you already understand the process.
You know which questions to ask and which professionals to involve.
But speed should never replace careful analysis.
A buyer who moves quickly into a bad deal hasn't achieved anything worthwhile.
Why Understanding Your Own Strengths Matters
Not every buyer should pursue the same kind of business.
A person with extensive sales experience might be well suited to acquiring a company with strong operations but weak business development.
Someone with a manufacturing background may recognize operational improvements that another buyer would overlook.
An experienced manager may be comfortable acquiring a company that needs better organizational systems.
The important thing is understanding your own capabilities.
What industries do you know?
What problems are you qualified to solve?
What kinds of businesses could you realistically manage?
And what risks would be outside your experience?
These questions help narrow your search.
They also make it easier to recognize an attractive opportunity when one appears.
Why Preparation Is More Valuable Than Looking at More Listings
Many prospective buyers spend enormous amounts of time browsing business-for-sale websites.
They review listing after listing, hoping the perfect opportunity will eventually appear.
But looking at more listings doesn't necessarily make you a better buyer.
You also need to understand how to evaluate the businesses you find.
That includes learning about valuation, financial analysis, financing, due diligence, negotiation, and deal structure.
It also means recognizing when a seller's expectations are unrealistic or when a company's financial performance doesn't support the proposed acquisition.
As I explained:
"The people who actually get from point A to B and actually complete a deal to acquire a profitable, good cash flowing business are the people who are prepared to do the deal." —David C. Barnett
Preparation helps you distinguish between a business that merely looks attractive and one that could become a sound investment.
And that distinction matters much more than the number of listings you've reviewed.
Don't Let Competition Push You Into a Bad Deal
When buyers discover how competitive the market can be, some begin feeling desperate.
They worry that every good business will be purchased by someone else.
They become reluctant to question the seller or negotiate the price.
They may even convince themselves that they need to accept unreasonable terms to complete a transaction.
That's exactly the wrong response.
Competition should encourage you to become better prepared.
It shouldn't encourage you to abandon your standards.
A good business acquisition requires two things.
First, you need to identify a business worth owning.
Second, you need to negotiate a transaction that allows you to earn an appropriate return while managing the risks.
If either element is missing, the acquisition may not make sense.
Final Thoughts: The Best-Prepared Buyer Has the Advantage
Interest in buying small businesses is growing.
And while the exact ratio of buyers to sellers is difficult to measure, the competition for attractive, profitable companies is real.
Good businesses with stable cash flow, reliable operations, and reasonable asking prices naturally attract attention.
But the answer isn't simply to pay more or rush into a transaction.
The answer is to become a more capable buyer.
Understand financial statements, cash flow, valuation, financing, due diligence, and negotiation.
Know what you're looking for.
Be ready to communicate your qualifications and act when a suitable opportunity appears.
And remain willing to walk away when the numbers don't make sense.
You don't need to win every acquisition opportunity. You need to complete the right transaction at the right price.
That's how you compete without turning a good business into a bad investment.
Learn How to Compete for the Right Business
If you're serious about buying a business, my Business Buyer Advantage program teaches you how to search for opportunities, analyze financial statements, value small businesses, understand financing, make offers, and conduct due diligence.
For buyers who want additional support, the Implementation Group provides ongoing coaching and opportunities to discuss real acquisition situations with other participants.
Explore Business Buyer Advantage
If you want to develop the financial skills needed to evaluate business cash flow, forecast future performance, and understand whether an acquisition is financially sustainable, explore my Cash Flow Forecasting and Business Plan Writing Program.
👉 Want deeper dives like this? Join my email list at DavidCBarnettList.com for early access to videos, insights, and 7 free bonus gifts.
No comments:
Post a Comment