Wednesday, October 29, 2025

Before You Hire a Business Broker—Watch This!

Business Broker Fees Explained: Commissions, Contracts & Red Flags

How much do business brokers charge, and how can you tell whether a broker is actually qualified to sell your business?

These are two important questions that every business owner should ask before signing a business broker agreement.

They're also questions that business buyers should understand because the relationship between a seller and their broker can have a major impact on whether an acquisition gets completed.

I recently received a question from someone who was frustrated with the way some business brokers operate.

He wanted to understand the typical financial arrangement between a business broker and a seller. He also wanted to know whether brokers are genuinely trying to sell businesses or simply collecting as many listings as possible.

Having worked as a business broker myself, I can tell you that these are legitimate concerns.

Let's look at how business broker commissions work, why different brokers charge different fees, and what separates a professional business broker from someone who may waste your time.


How Much Do Business Brokers Charge?

One of the first things business owners want to know is how much they'll have to pay a broker to sell their company.

The answer depends on several factors, including the size of the business, the broker's experience, the competitive environment, and the services being provided.

Based on the transactions I've encountered across North America, business broker commissions commonly range from 8% to 12% of the sale price, with 10% being a frequently encountered rate in the smaller-business market.

That isn't a universal industry standard or a guaranteed current quote. It's an observation from the transactions we've worked on.

When I worked as a business broker, my fee structure was a little different.

I charged an upfront engagement fee of a few thousand dollars to help cover the cost of evaluating the business, preparing marketing materials, and advertising.

Then, when the business sold, I charged a commission.

My commission was divided into two categories:

  • 12% of the business value

  • 7% of the real estate value, if commercial property was included in the transaction

Why the difference?

Because selling an operating business requires different expertise from selling commercial real estate.

At the time, commercial real estate agents in my market were charging around 7%, so I used that rate for the property portion while charging more for the business itself.

What Fees Can a Business Broker Charge?

Business broker fees aren't always limited to a commission at closing.

Depending on the brokerage, you might encounter several types of fees.

Engagement Fees

An engagement fee is an upfront payment made when you hire the broker.

It may help cover business valuation work, preparation of the confidential business profile, and initial marketing expenses.

Not every broker charges one.

An established specialist with a strong track record may be in a better position to require an engagement fee than someone who's just entering the industry.

Monthly Marketing Fees

Some intermediaries, particularly those working on larger transactions, charge ongoing marketing or advisory fees.

These payments may cover buyer outreach, advertising, and other work performed throughout the engagement.

In some arrangements, the fees are credited against the eventual success commission.

In others, they're additional expenses.

Success Commissions

The success commission is generally payable when the business is sold, according to the terms of the agreement.

This is often the largest component of the broker's compensation.

Before signing, make sure you understand exactly how the commission is calculated, what transaction value it applies to, and when payment becomes due.

Why Do Some Business Brokers Charge More Than Others?

Here's something I think business owners sometimes overlook.

Business brokerages are businesses themselves.

They have to think about marketing, reputation, positioning, competition, and profitability just like any other company.

Imagine a brokerage that specializes exclusively in pharmacies.

Suppose it has a strong record of completed pharmacy transactions and an established network of qualified buyers.

That brokerage can make a compelling argument for charging higher upfront fees because its specialization may offer meaningful value to pharmacy owners.

Now compare that with someone who has just started working as a business broker in a highly competitive market.

They might waive engagement fees, avoid monthly charges, or negotiate their commission simply to attract clients.

Neither fee structure automatically tells you whether the broker is good or bad.

But it does tell you something about how that brokerage positions itself in the marketplace.

And that's why I wouldn't choose a broker based on price alone.

Why Some Business Brokers Focus on Getting Listings Instead of Selling Businesses

This is where I think the industry gets particularly interesting.

When I first entered business brokerage, I was encouraged to take almost any listing I could get.

The idea was to build up a portfolio of ten or twelve businesses for sale.

Those listings would generate inquiries from potential buyers.

I could then build a buyer email list and use that growing network to attract more sellers.

It sounds like a reasonable business development strategy.

But there's a problem.

Getting a business listed for sale and actually selling that business are two completely different accomplishments.

Some brokers approach the industry as though they're selling residential real estate.

In real estate, an agent can list a property and potentially benefit when another agent brings the buyer.

Business brokerage doesn't always work that way.

An overpriced business with unrealistic seller expectations can sit on the market without producing a viable transaction.

And the broker may have invested considerable time in something that was never likely to sell.

The Candy Store Approach to Business Brokerage

Over time, experienced brokers often realize that having more listings isn't necessarily better.

They need listings that buyers can actually purchase.

I like to compare this with running a candy store.

A retailer wants products on the shelves that customers will buy at prices they're willing to pay.

If everything is priced too high, the store isn't going to sell much.

Business brokerage works in a similar way.

A professional broker needs to understand what buyers are looking for, what they can afford, and whether the business's financial performance supports the asking price.

“I need to get things for sale that I can actually sell.”
—David C. Barnett

That realization changes how a broker approaches potential clients.

Instead of accepting every business owner's desired asking price, the broker starts having more difficult conversations.

What is the company's actual cash flow?

What kind of buyer is likely to purchase it?

How much financing will that buyer require?

Will the business generate enough cash to service the acquisition debt?

If the seller's expectations don't align with those realities, a qualified broker needs to explain the problem.

And sometimes the correct advice is that the owner shouldn't sell yet.

Why an Overpriced Business Can Be Difficult to Sell

Imagine a seller believes their business is worth $1 million.

But when you analyze its earnings, financing requirements, and the buyer's expected return, the numbers don't support that valuation.

The broker has two choices.

They can accept the listing at $1 million and hope someone eventually makes an offer.

Or they can explain why the asking price may not be realistic and help the owner understand what the market can support.

I strongly prefer the second approach.

A business buyer isn't simply deciding whether they like the company.

They also have to determine whether they can finance the purchase and earn enough money afterward to justify the investment.

The seller's asking price doesn't change those financial realities.

A broker who understands business cash flow and acquisition financing is much better positioned to help both parties reach an agreement.

Business Broker Red Flags: What Buyers and Sellers Should Watch For

Not every frustrating broker is necessarily dishonest or incompetent.

Some are inexperienced.

Others may have developed habits from industries where transactions work differently.

But there are warning signs worth investigating.

1. The Broker Accepts an Unrealistic Asking Price

If a broker agrees with every valuation expectation without explaining how the price is supported, I'd want to know why.

Ask how the business was valued and whether the asking price is realistic given the financing a buyer may need.

2. The Broker Won't Allow Meaningful Buyer-Seller Conversations

I've encountered situations where buyers were told they couldn't speak directly with the seller until an offer had been submitted.

I think that's a serious problem.

Buying a business involves uncertainties that can't always be resolved by reviewing documents.

The buyer needs to understand the seller, the business, and the relationships that make it work.

“The two people have to get to know each other. They have to trust each other and they have to want to do a deal together.”
—David C. Barnett

Confidentiality and an orderly process are important, but a broker shouldn't unnecessarily prevent the parties from developing the understanding needed to complete a transaction.

3. The Broker Can't Explain the Buyer's Financing Requirements

A business might look attractive on paper, but can a qualified buyer actually finance it?

If the broker hasn't considered the likely down payment, borrowing requirements, and debt service, that concerns me.

4. The Broker Relies on Marketing Instead of Experience

Beautiful brochures and polished presentations are nice.

But they don't prove that someone understands business valuation, negotiations, or acquisition financing.

I'd rather see evidence of successful transactions and thoughtful preparation.

5. The Broker Doesn't Understand the Importance of Trust

Business acquisitions aren't simply exchanges of money for assets.

Buyers and sellers often need to cooperate through due diligence, financing, closing, and transition.

Seller financing can make that relationship even more important because the seller remains financially exposed to the buyer's future performance.

A broker who doesn't understand those relationships may make a difficult process even harder.

How to Choose a Business Broker to Sell Your Business

If you're a business owner preparing to sell, I would encourage you to investigate the individual broker before signing an agreement.

Your business may be one of the largest assets you own.

Why would you hand responsibility for selling it to someone without carefully checking their qualifications?

Here's what I would do.

Ask about their experience. Find out how long they've been working in business brokerage and what types of businesses they've successfully sold.

Investigate their reputation. Speak with business owners, professional advisors, and people in your network who may have experience with the broker.

Request examples of their work. Ask to review sample confidential business profiles or confidential information memorandums (CIMs) they've prepared for other clients, with sensitive information appropriately removed.

Evaluate the financial logic. Look at those examples from a buyer's perspective. Does the asking price make sense relative to cash flow and financing?

Understand the contract. Review the commission, engagement fees, exclusivity period, termination provisions, and any other financial obligations.

And remember that a brokerage's brand name isn't the same thing as the individual broker's competence.

Large firms may have strong reputations, but the service you receive ultimately depends on the person handling your transaction.

What If You're a Buyer Dealing With a Difficult Business Broker?

Unfortunately, buyers don't always get to choose the broker.

If the business you want is represented by a particular brokerage, you may have to work through that intermediary.

And sometimes the broker's relationship with the seller can complicate negotiations.

I've seen situations where buyers and sellers wanted to move forward, but disagreements involving the broker created additional difficulties.

The listing agreement may also limit the seller's options until the contract expires or is otherwise resolved.

As a buyer, I would focus on understanding the situation, communicating professionally, and making sure any discussions respect the seller's existing contractual obligations.

I wouldn't assume that bypassing the broker is a simple or risk-free solution.

What Makes a Good Business Broker?

I think the best brokers understand something that inexperienced brokers sometimes miss.

Their job isn't simply to collect listings.

It's to help create transactions that actually make sense.

That requires understanding the seller's expectations, the buyer's needs, the financial performance of the business, and the risks involved in transferring ownership.

“The role of a business broker is to create a relationship between a buyer and a seller so that they can trust each other.”
—David C. Barnett

A good broker should be willing to have difficult conversations.

They should explain why an asking price may be unrealistic, why financing could be a problem, or why a business needs more preparation before going to market.

Those conversations aren't always comfortable.

But they're much more valuable than agreeing to everything a seller wants to hear.

The Bottom Line: Broker Fees Matter, but Competence Matters More

If you're selling a business, don't automatically choose the broker with the lowest commission.

And don't assume the broker charging the highest fee is necessarily the most qualified.

Look at what you're actually receiving.

Can the broker explain your business's value?

Do they understand the likely buyer?

Can they prepare a credible business profile?

Do they understand how acquisition financing works?

And can they help build the trust required to complete a transaction?

Business broker fees are important, but choosing the wrong broker can create problems that extend far beyond the commission.

The goal isn't simply to list your business for sale. The goal is to find a qualified buyer and complete a transaction that makes sense for everyone involved.

Get Help Buying or Selling a Small Business

If you're considering buying a business and want help understanding valuations, financing, due diligence, or deal structure, my Business Buyer Advantage program provides online training, group coaching, and consulting services designed to help you make informed acquisition decisions.

I've worked with buyers and sellers through many of the challenges discussed here, and my goal is to help people approach business transactions with a clearer understanding of the risks and opportunities.

Learn more about Business Buyer Advantage:

https://businessbuyeradvantage.com/

Monday, October 27, 2025

Live Get the most from the online review game with minimal effort

 


Get the most from the online review game with minimal effort 

New Livestream guest- George Swetlitz from Right Response AI

I’m happy to have George join me on a live broadcast.

George understands the world of online advertising and has lead real world business rollups that depended on local advertising.

Tune in and as we’ll be discussing online reviews and how it is crucial in getting customers from platforms such as Google Maps.

This is a ‘must see event’ for anyone who does business with customers.

Be sure to join live so that you can ask questions, replay will be available.

Set yourself a reminder on YouTube here: https://youtube.com/live/CGhIGep-CP4 

We’ll be going live Monday October 27, 2025 at 1PM Atlantic Time and 12 Noon Eastern Time

See you there!

David C Barnett


Saturday, October 25, 2025

How to Value a Pre-Revenue Startup

This week, I want to talk about pre-revenue startups, because people keep asking me how to value them.



What Is (and Isn’t) a Business

If you’ve followed me for a while, you know my rule:

To be a business, you need people, capital, and a place—all working together to produce cash flow.

A pre-revenue startup has none of that last part. There’s no cash flow yet.

Instead, investors are pouring money into an idea, hoping that one day it will produce revenue and a return on investment.

That makes it risky—very risky.
It’s like funding an oil exploration company: you spend money drilling holes, and if you don’t hit oil, all that time, energy, and capital just disappears.

So How Do You Value a Pre-Revenue Startup?

Let’s look at an analogy.

If I went out and bought a dump truck, a backhoe, and some wooden forms to build house foundations, and parked them all in my yard, what would I have?

I wouldn’t have a business yet—but I’d have a pre-revenue startup foundation company.

If I wanted to sell it before I ever got my first customer, would it be worth something?
Sure—it would have liquidation value, based on what someone else would pay for the equipment.

That’s the same principle that applies to startups that have built technology, software, or intellectual property.

The Principle of Substitution

Let’s say a big company spots your startup and says,

“Wow, if we had this widget inside our existing platform, we could make a ton of money.”

They can see the value in your technology—but you don’t have any revenue yet.

What happens next? They apply something called the principle of substitution.

They ask:

  • Could we build something similar ourselves?

  • How long would it take?

  • How many people and how much money would we need?

If they estimate it would cost them, say, $500,000 to build, they might offer to buy your startup for less than that, because it saves them time and risk.

They might even offer slightly more if they can see that your solution already works, since building it themselves could introduce delays or surprises.

But ultimately, the value comes down to what the acquirer thinks it’s worth to them, not what you think it’s worth based on “potential.”

The Harsh Truth About “Potential”

Startup founders often say,

“Yeah, but look at what this could become!”

And that’s when I point them to another concept I’ve covered in my videos: Blue Sky.

Blue sky is the imagined, hopeful future value that might exist one day—but that nobody will pay for today.

The reality is that when a larger company acquires your startup, they’re not paying for your potential.
They’re paying for what they can do with it themselves.

The Bottom Line

The valuation of a pre-revenue startup is really just a combination of:

  • Liquidation value (what your assets are worth today), and

  • Substitution value (what it would cost someone else to build the same thing).

Everything beyond that—“potential,” “vision,” or “what this could be”—is blue sky.

It’s speculative, and in most cases, it’s worth exactly zero until real, repeatable cash flow appears

Learn How to Buy or Evaluate a Business the Right Way

If you’re serious about buying a business, check out my online course at BusinessBuyerAdvantage.com.

Don’t waste your hard-earned money chasing dreams and “potential.” Learn to evaluate businesses the right way before you buy.

👉 Want deeper dives like this? Join my email list at DavidCBarnettList.com  for early access to videos, insights, and 7 free bonus gifts.

Cheers, 

David C. Barnett.


Friday, October 24, 2025

A great Interview with the host of We Close Notes Podcast Scott Carson

 

Thinking of diversifying into business note investing? This ain't your grandma's real estate note. David Barnett joins us to expose the real risks of buying paper backed by businesses.

Forget passive income dreams; this is a hands-on (or hands-off-and-lose-everything) game. Buckle up, buttercup, because we're diving headfirst into the due diligence disasters and non-compete nightmares that await the unsuspecting note investor.

We're serving up a healthy dose of reality – this episode will have you questioning every "opportunity" landing in your inbox.

Wednesday, October 22, 2025

Top 5 Biggest Mistakes when trying to sell a business

5 Biggest Mistakes to Avoid When Selling a Small Business

Selling a small business can be one of the biggest financial decisions you'll ever make.

You've spent years building the company, serving customers, managing employees, and taking risks. Naturally, when the time comes to sell, you want to receive a fair price and move on to the next chapter of your life.

But here's something I've learned from working with business owners and buyers: many of the biggest mistakes people make when selling a business happen long before they meet their first buyer.

Poor financial records, an owner-dependent operation, unrealistic asking prices, and misunderstandings about business value can all prevent an otherwise profitable company from selling.

And some of these problems take years to correct.

I want to walk you through the five biggest mistakes I see when owners try to sell their small businesses, explain why they matter, and show you what you can do to avoid them.



Mistake #5: Neglecting Your Financial Records Before Selling

Let's start with one of the fastest ways to destroy credibility with a prospective buyer: having financial records that don't clearly demonstrate how much money your business makes.

When someone considers buying your business, they're not simply interested in your revenue.

They want to understand its profitability, cash flow, expenses, and financial history.

And they're not the only ones who need convincing.

The buyer's banker, accountant, and other advisors will also examine your financial information before supporting the transaction.

If your books are incomplete, inconsistent, or poorly organized, you're immediately introducing uncertainty.

That uncertainty translates into risk.

Why Unsupported Add-Backs Can Kill a Business Sale

One problem I encounter regularly is the use of unsupported add-backs.

An add-back is an expense recorded in the business that a seller argues won't continue under new ownership.

For example, suppose you claim that your business spends $20,000 annually on personal travel.

You tell the buyer that this money should be added back to the company's earnings because the new owner won't incur that expense.

That might be reasonable.

But can you prove it?

When the buyer begins due diligence, they're going to want evidence.

They may ask for receipts, invoices, and transaction details supporting that $20,000 adjustment.

If you can't produce them, your explanation may fall apart.

I've seen broker packages containing suspiciously round figures for discretionary expenses, without sufficient documentation to support them.

The problem is that these adjustments can artificially inflate the earnings being presented to buyers.

And if the buyer can't verify those earnings, the transaction may collapse.

How to Avoid This Mistake

Before selling your business, make sure you can demonstrate its profitability through reliable financial statements, tax returns, and supporting records.

If you're claiming add-backs, document them carefully.

Don't rely on guesses or assumptions.

The objective is to make it easier for buyers and their lenders to understand the financial performance they're actually purchasing.

Mistake #4: Running a Business That Depends Entirely on You

The second major problem I see is an owner-dependent business.

This happens when the company's success relies too heavily on the personal knowledge, relationships, and daily involvement of its owner.

Maybe you're the only person who knows how to price jobs.

Perhaps your biggest customers deal exclusively with you.

Or maybe every important decision requires your approval.

That might work while you're running the business.

But it creates a serious problem when you want to sell.

Buyers Need to Know Whether the Cash Flow Will Continue

When evaluating a business, buyers are generally trying to answer two important questions.

First, how much cash flow does the business generate?

Second, will that cash flow continue after they become the owner?

The first question is primarily financial.

The second is about transferability.

If the business can't operate without you, the buyer is taking on substantial risk.

They're not simply purchasing an established company.

They're also trying to acquire years of knowledge and relationships that may exist only in your head.

Document Your Systems and Processes

This is why I encourage business owners to create systems that employees and future owners can follow.

You don't necessarily need enormous operating manuals.

You might use shared folders, spreadsheets, checklists, written procedures, or a database to organize how your business operates.

For example, a roofing company might document:

  • How customer inquiries are handled

  • How employees measure and estimate jobs

  • How pricing decisions are made

  • How projects are scheduled

  • How completed work is inspected

The important thing is that these processes can be demonstrated to someone else.

You want to show a prospective buyer that the business has an operating system independent of your personal involvement.

Owner Dependency Can Affect Your Deal Structure

If the buyer believes the business depends heavily on you, they may require a longer transition period.

Instead of receiving the purchase price and retiring immediately, you could find yourself working alongside the buyer for months or even years.

The buyer may also request seller financing, earn-outs, royalties, or payments tied to future performance.

Why?

Because they're concerned that the business's earnings could decline once you leave.

The less transferable your business is, the more difficult it may be to achieve a clean exit.

Mistake #3: Waiting Too Long to Prepare Your Business for Sale

This is one of the most preventable mistakes I see.

Many owners don't start preparing to sell until they've already decided they want to leave.

By then, they may not have enough time to make meaningful improvements.

Suppose you decide today that you want to sell your business.

You realize your financial records need improvement.

It may take a couple of years to establish a convincing history of clean financial reporting.

Or perhaps you discover that most of the company's operating knowledge exists in your head.

Documenting those processes could take a year, and you'll still need time to demonstrate that the systems work.

These aren't problems you can necessarily solve in a few weeks.

When Should You Start Planning Your Business Exit?

I don't necessarily think every entrepreneur needs a detailed exit plan on the day they launch a startup.

Many new businesses never reach sustainable profitability.

But I do believe there's an important point when owners should begin taking exit planning seriously.

It's when the business generates enough income to pay you a fair market wage for your work and still produces additional profit.

Imagine that managing a business like yours would normally pay $100,000 per year.

Your company now generates $140,000 after its other operating expenses.

That means you can compensate yourself for the work you're doing and still have $40,000 left over.

You've reached a point where you're building something that may have transferable value beyond your personal labour.

That's when I would encourage you to start preparing for an eventual exit.

Retirement Isn't the Only Reason People Sell Businesses

Many owners think they have plenty of time because retirement is still 15 or 20 years away.

But retirement is only one reason a business might need to be sold.

Other common reasons include burnout, boredom, fatigue, divorce, poor health, and relocation.

Those circumstances don't always arrive according to your preferred schedule.

That's why I believe exit planning should begin long before you expect to sell.

You want the option to leave when circumstances change, rather than discovering that your business isn't ready.

Mistake #2: Overpricing Your Business

One of the biggest mistakes sellers make is setting an asking price based on what they want instead of what the business can support.

Maybe you need $1 million to retire comfortably.

Perhaps you've invested $800,000 into the business over the years.

Or you've heard that another company in your industry sold for a particularly high multiple.

None of those facts automatically establishes what your business is worth.

Business value depends on the economic benefits a buyer expects to receive and the risks involved in receiving them.

Why an Unrealistic Asking Price Can Drive Away Qualified Buyers

Let's imagine your business is worth approximately $379,000 based on its financial performance and the market for similar businesses.

You decide to list it for $600,000 because you want plenty of room to negotiate.

What happens?

Experienced buyers may immediately recognize that the asking price is unrealistic.

Instead of contacting you, they move on to other opportunities.

You might still attract inexperienced buyers who are excited about the business.

Some may even submit offers.

But when they approach a lender, the financing may not work because the company's cash flow doesn't support the proposed purchase price.

Now you've wasted valuable time.

Why Time Becomes Your Enemy After Deciding to Sell

Here's something I think sellers underestimate.

When you finally decide you want to leave your business, something has usually changed.

Maybe you're exhausted.

Maybe you want to relocate.

Perhaps your health or family circumstances have changed.

Whatever the reason, you're no longer as committed to operating the business as you once were.

And that can affect performance.

You might become less attentive to customers, postpone improvements, or stop investing the same energy into employees and operations.

Over time, those changes can begin affecting revenue and profitability.

Once declining performance appears in your financial statements, buyers become more cautious.

As I've explained:

“When you've made the decision to sell, time is not on your side.”
—David C. Barnett

That's why I encourage sellers to price their businesses realistically and move with purpose.

A Better Approach to Business Pricing

When we've completed a Most Probable Selling Price evaluation, I've sometimes recommended listing a business slightly above the estimated value to allow for negotiation.

For example, if the estimated selling price is $379,000, we might suggest asking $399,000.

But I've also worked with owners who preferred to ask $379,000 because they wanted to attract serious buyers quickly.

Their reasoning was simple.

A realistic price could generate more interest and potentially give them more options.

They weren't trying to achieve an imaginary valuation.

They wanted to complete a transaction.

Mistake #1: Confusing Enterprise Value With the Transaction Price

This is the biggest mistake on my list because it can derail a transaction even after the buyer and seller believe they've agreed on the value of the business.

Enterprise value and the amount a seller receives at closing aren't necessarily the same thing.

Let's look at why.

When a buyer values a business, they're considering the cash flow it can generate and the resources required to produce that cash flow.

But in many small-business transactions, the parties structure the purchase as an asset sale.

That means the buyer acquires specified assets rather than automatically acquiring every asset and liability of the seller's company.

Some items may remain with the seller.

And some resources needed to operate the business may need to be supplied separately by the buyer.

Working Capital Can Change the Economics of a Deal

Imagine you're selling a business whose customers normally take 30 to 60 days to pay their invoices.

Your company needs cash to pay employees, suppliers, rent, and other expenses while waiting to collect those receivables.

That cash requirement is part of how the business operates.

Now suppose you negotiate a purchase price based on the company's earnings.

At closing, you tell the buyer that you intend to keep all the accounts receivable and other operating capital.

What happens?

The buyer may need to invest additional money immediately just to keep the business running.

That changes the economics of the acquisition.

I've seen deals run into serious problems because sellers assume they can receive the agreed value of the operating business while also withdrawing the resources needed to support its cash flow.

This is why working capital needs to be discussed early.

Deferred Equipment Replacement Can Also Affect Value

Here's another example.

Suppose you're selling a transportation business.

The company generates attractive cash flow, but all its trucks are ten years old.

A buyer realizes they'll need to replace several vehicles shortly after the acquisition.

Those replacement costs don't necessarily create additional earnings.

They're expenditures required to maintain the company's existing operations.

So the buyer has to account for them when deciding how much to invest.

The same principle applies to machinery, equipment, vehicles, and other assets that may require significant replacement or repair.

Understand the Complete Transaction

The exact relationship between enterprise value, equity value, working capital adjustments, debt, and closing proceeds depends on the transaction structure.

But the practical lesson is straightforward.

Don't assume that agreeing on a business valuation means you've agreed on every financial component of the transaction.

As I explain to sellers:

“Enterprise value and transaction price are not the same thing.”
—David C. Barnett

You need to understand which assets are included, which liabilities remain, how working capital will be handled, and whether additional investments will be required.

Those details can substantially affect what the buyer is willing to pay and what you ultimately receive.

How to Prepare Your Small Business for a Successful Sale

When I look at these five mistakes together, I see a common problem.

Owners often wait until they're emotionally ready to leave before preparing their businesses for someone else to own.

But by that point, their options may already be limited.

Here's how I think about preparing a business for sale.

First, build financial records that clearly demonstrate profitability.

Second, develop systems that allow the business to operate without your constant involvement.

Third, understand what your company is realistically worth.

Fourth, consider what a buyer will need to invest in working capital, equipment, and the transition.

Finally, give yourself enough time to address problems before they become deal-breaking issues.

You don't need to wait until retirement is approaching.

In fact, knowing what your business is worth can help you make better decisions while you're still growing it.

Should you buy that new machine?

Should you replace the trucks?

Would expanding into another market improve the company's value?

Those decisions become easier to evaluate when you understand how buyers assess business performance and transferability.

The Best Time to Prepare Your Business for Sale Is Before You Need to Sell

One of the things I tell owners is that I can often provide much more comprehensive help when they approach me ten or fifteen years before an intended sale.

Why?

Because there's time to make changes.

We can identify weaknesses in the financial records, improve operating systems, reduce owner dependency, and develop a realistic exit strategy.

When someone comes to me and says they need to sell immediately, the conversation is often very different.

Instead of discussing how to improve the business, we may need to focus on managing expectations about the transaction that's realistically possible.

And sometimes the owner discovers that the available deal terms aren't what they expected.

That's why I encourage people to think about selling earlier rather than later.

“Having an idea of what the business is worth is going to inform your ability to make other decisions inside the business.”
—David C. Barnett

A successful business exit isn't something you improvise when you're ready to retire. It's something you prepare for while you still have the time and flexibility to make improvements.

Get Professional Help Preparing Your Business for Sale

If you're thinking about selling your small business now or in the next several years, my team and I can help you understand what your company may be worth and what you need to prepare before approaching buyers.

Through How to Sell My Own Business, we offer a zero-commission consulting approach that we've used since 2016.

We can help evaluate your business, prepare the information buyers need, develop a confidential marketing strategy, and guide you through the sale process.

Whether you're ready to sell or simply want to understand your options, preparing early can help you make better decisions and avoid costly surprises.

Learn more about our business selling and exit preparation services:

https://howtosellmyownbusiness.com/

Saturday, October 18, 2025

Why You Should Never Pay a Seller for Future Potential

 I want to talk a little bit about business valuation, specifically when you’re buying an existing franchise location—and how to avoid one of the biggest traps buyers fall into: paying for future potential instead of proven performance. https://youtu.be/Yu1xkgI8X9I 



The Franchise Valuation Case

I was recently hired to evaluate a franchise restaurant that was for sale.

When I perform a business valuation, I start by normalizing the income statement to calculate Seller’s Discretionary Earnings (SDE)—the total cash flow available to an owner-operator.

That SDE needs to be enough to:

  1. Pay the owner a reasonable salary

  2. Cover any loan payments for the purchase

  3. Provide a return on the buyer’s investment

  4. Cover CAPex needs as machinery and equipment wear out

Once I have that SDE, I compare it to data from hundreds of past business sales—properly normalized and tracked by the International Business Brokers Association (IBBA).

In this case, the restaurant’s cash flow supported a valuation of about $175,000. That represents the enterprise value—the business plus its inventory, working capital, and equipment, but not including real estate (since it was a leased location).

The Problem: Renovations and “Future Growth”

Because it’s a franchise, there were some obligations tied to the sale.

The franchisor required the new owner to complete a $100,000 renovation and pay a $30,000 franchise fee for the latest décor and menu updates.

The seller and their broker claimed these upgrades would increase sales by 20%—and therefore, profits would rise too.

So, they were asking for $150,000 for the business, plus the $130,000 investment for the upgrades.

What the Buyer Was Really Paying For

Here’s the thing: the only thing we know for certain is the cash flow that exists today.

If you agree to pay for the business plus invest in renovations because someone told you sales “should” go up, you’re essentially paying the seller for your own hard work and risk.

That’s not smart buying.

As I always teach in my business buyer seminars:

You pay for what you get. You buy for what you believe you can create.

But you never pay the seller for the future potential that you have to deliver.

The Reality Check

So I told my client:

If the cash flow supports a value of $175,000, and you have to invest $130,000 after buying it, your offer should be $175,000 minus $130,000 — or roughly $45–50K.

He made the offer.

And of course, the seller said no.

The business has now been sitting on the market for over two and a half years because nobody is willing to pay for blue sky.

“But I’ll Benefit From the Renovation…”

My client asked a fair question:

“Shouldn’t I pay a bit more since I’ll benefit from the renovations?”

Here’s the logic I shared:

If those renovations truly guaranteed higher sales and profits, the seller would have already made them.

They’d spend the money, see the higher profits, and then sell the business for a higher price.

But they’re not doing that—because they know it’s a gamble.

They want you to take on that risk and pay them as if the results were already proven.

That’s not how smart buyers think.

The Bottom Line

When evaluating a franchise (or any business), pay for the results that exist today, not the story of what “might” happen tomorrow.

If a franchisor or broker is trying to sell you on “potential,” remember: Potential is free. Proven cash flow costs money.

👉 Want deeper dives like this? Join my email list at DavidCBarnettList.com for early access to videos, insights, and 7 free bonus gifts.