Monday, November 16, 2026

Why Competing Against Yourself Works Better Than You Think

How to Compete Against Yourself: A Small Business Marketing Strategy That Attracts More Customers

What if one of your biggest competitors was actually another business you owned?

It sounds strange, but years ago, I helped a moving company create a second brand that appeared to compete with its existing business.

The results were fascinating.

The company started attracting different types of customers, learned more about what people were willing to pay, and discovered opportunities to fill gaps in its schedule.

And sometimes, customers would call both businesses without realizing they were speaking to the same company.

This story goes back to my days working at Yellow Pages, but the underlying marketing lesson is still relevant today.

Different customers value different things, and your marketing should reflect those differences.

Let's look at how this strategy worked, what the business owner learned, and how you might apply the underlying principles to your own business without misleading customers.



What Working at Yellow Pages Taught Me About Small Business Marketing

Before I became involved in business brokerage, I spent approximately seven years working at Yellow Pages.

For younger readers, Yellow Pages was essentially the local business search engine before smartphones and online search became part of everyday life.

If you needed a plumber, electrician, moving company, or another local service provider, you'd open the phone book and look under the appropriate category.

Businesses could purchase advertisements of different sizes.

Some had full-page ads.

Others had half-page or quarter-page displays.

And smaller companies might have only a basic listing or a small informational box.

As a Yellow Pages representative, I spent a lot of time visiting local businesses and talking with owners about their operations.

I learned how they made money, what their margins looked like, and which customers they wanted to attract.

It was almost like getting an MBA in small business.

But one of the most interesting lessons came from understanding how customers responded to different advertisements.

Why Different Customers Respond to Different Advertising

Imagine someone needs a plumber immediately.

They have a serious problem at home and want someone reliable to fix it.

If money isn't their biggest concern, they might open the Yellow Pages and choose one of the companies with the largest advertisements.

Why?

Because a large, professional-looking advertisement can create an impression of credibility and success.

The customer may assume the company is established, experienced, and capable of handling the problem.

Now imagine another customer who needs plumbing work but has a very limited budget.

That person might approach the search differently.

Instead of calling one or two companies, they may contact every plumber listed in the directory.

They're looking for the lowest possible price.

Why Some Businesses Only Attracted Price Shoppers

I remember speaking with business owners who didn't advertise in Yellow Pages.

Some would tell me that the directory was useless because everyone who called was simply looking for the cheapest price.

But there was a reason for that.

The customers who wanted convenience and perceived reliability were often calling the companies with prominent advertisements.

The people contacting every single listing were frequently the price-sensitive shoppers.

As I explained in the video:

"You are only hearing from the people that are willing to invest hours calling every last person and trying to get the best price." —David C. Barnett

The advertising wasn't necessarily attracting the wrong customers.

The business was only visible to a particular segment of the market.

That distinction became important when I started working with a local moving company.

The Moving Company That Wanted Two Different Types of Customers

One day, I was visiting a moving company that operated under a well-known national moving brand.

The business had professional trucks, established systems, and a reputation for providing quality service.

It was positioned toward customers who wanted a dependable moving experience.

And in the moving industry, that can be a valuable market.

The High-End Moving Market

Think about someone being transferred across the country by their employer.

They have a three-bedroom house filled with furniture, dishes, electronics, and personal belongings.

Their employer is paying for the move.

Naturally, they want a moving company that will handle everything carefully.

They're more concerned about reliability and service quality than finding the absolute lowest price.

For a full-service moving company, these customers can be attractive because they're willing to pay for the additional service.

But there's another market.

The Budget Moving Market

Not everyone needs a full-service move.

Some people simply want help moving the contents of a one-bedroom apartment.

Others are moving between small homes or need assistance with a relatively straightforward job.

These customers may care much more about price.

And for an established moving company, serving them can still make financial sense.

Suppose you have a truck and crew available for half a day.

If there's no premium-priced job scheduled, a smaller move at a lower rate might still contribute toward wages, vehicle costs, and other expenses.

The challenge is attracting those customers without undermining the premium brand.

That's where our idea came from.

The Strategy: Create a Second Brand for Budget Customers

The moving company already had a large advertisement in Yellow Pages.

It was positioned toward customers who wanted professional, full-service moving.

I suggested creating another advertisement aimed specifically at the budget market.

Instead of using the established moving company's branding, we developed a different business name.

We called it Your Apartment and Mini Home Movers.

The advertisement focused on smaller jobs, such as apartment moves, mini-home moves, and after-hours moving services.

The message emphasized affordability.

Why We Positioned the Second Advertisement Differently

In the Yellow Pages directory, the largest advertisements appeared prominently within each business category.

Smaller listings were placed elsewhere, often according to alphabetical order.

So we chose a name beginning with a letter near the end of the alphabet.

That meant the budget advertisement would appear in a different location from the company's premium advertisement.

A customer browsing the directory might encounter both listings during their search.

But each advertisement communicated a different value proposition.

One emphasized professional service and established branding.

The other emphasized affordability and smaller moving jobs.

The goal was to reach two different customer segments.

How We Tracked Calls From the Second Advertisement

Back then, businesses often used telephone systems with multiple lines.

The moving company had several phone lines connected to its office system.

Normally, customers called the main advertised number.

If that line was busy, another line could handle the call.

I suggested advertising one of the company's additional phone numbers under the budget moving brand.

That way, the owner could identify which advertisement generated the inquiry.

If the main line received a call, it was likely associated with the premium brand.

If the other number rang directly, the call was coming through the budget advertisement.

Today, businesses can achieve similar tracking through dedicated phone numbers, website analytics, and call-tracking systems.

But at the time, this was a practical way to learn which advertisements were producing results.

What Happened When the Moving Company Competed Against Itself?

When I returned to visit the owner the following year, he was excited about what he'd discovered.

The second advertisement had produced an unexpected benefit.

Some customers were calling the premium moving company first.

Then, after continuing their search, they would call the budget number.

They didn't realize they were contacting the same underlying business.

The owner could recognize what was happening because he knew which phone line was ringing.

And he started noticing patterns in how customers shopped for moving services.

The Business Learned More About Price Sensitivity

Suppose a customer called the main number asking about moving a one-bedroom apartment.

The company might provide an estimate based on its regular hourly rate.

Later, the same customer might call the budget number.

If the moving company had unused capacity, the owner could offer a lower rate.

That might help fill an otherwise empty part of the schedule.

But if the company was already busy, he might quote a higher price because there was little reason to discount the work.

Sometimes customers would eventually return to the original company and book the move.

That helped the owner understand how his pricing compared with other businesses in the market.

What the Owner Learned About Demand

Over time, the owner began adjusting prices based on factors such as available capacity, the time of the month, and the type of moving job.

He could see that customers responded differently to different messages.

He also gained a better understanding of how much flexibility existed in his pricing.

The second advertisement wasn't simply generating more calls.

It was giving him information about the market.

And that information helped him make better decisions.

Expanding the Strategy to Three Advertisements

After seeing the results, we decided to take the idea further.

The following year, the company used three advertisements in the same Yellow Pages category.

The first was its large premium advertisement.

We adjusted the messaging to emphasize executive moves, careful handling, and full-service relocation.

The second was a smaller display advertisement under the main company's branding.

That advertisement focused more on smaller residential moves.

The third was the separate budget-oriented listing for apartment and mini-home moving services.

Each advertisement appealed to a different type of customer.

When I returned the following year, the owner could clearly see that the advertisements were attracting different groups of people.

The business had learned how to position its services for multiple customer segments.

And it could use that information to make better decisions about scheduling, pricing, and marketing.

What This Story Teaches Us About Customer Segmentation

The biggest lesson isn't that every business should create a competitor.

It's that customers don't all make purchasing decisions for the same reasons.

Some prioritize quality.

Others prioritize convenience.

Some care about reputation and reliability.

And others are primarily interested in price.

If you advertise only one message, you may appeal strongly to one group while overlooking another.

Premium Customers and Budget Customers Want Different Things

A customer hiring a full-service moving company may want careful packing, reliable scheduling, and experienced employees.

Someone moving a small apartment may simply need a truck and a few hours of labor.

Those customers have different expectations.

And they may respond to completely different advertisements.

The same principle applies to many other service businesses.

A company might offer premium services for customers who value convenience while also offering a simpler, lower-cost option for more price-sensitive buyers.

The important thing is understanding what each customer segment actually needs.

Can You Use This Marketing Strategy Today?

Absolutely.

The tools have changed dramatically since my Yellow Pages days.

Today, businesses can create websites, landing pages, advertising campaigns, and dedicated phone numbers relatively easily.

That makes it possible to test different marketing messages without purchasing multiple advertisements in a printed directory.

But there's an important distinction between creating separate brands and misleading customers into believing they're dealing with unrelated competitors.

A Modern Example: Parking Lot Striping

The story came back to mind when I saw a social media post from Jared D. Harden, who operates in the parking lot striping industry.

He was frustrated about spending time preparing quotes for customers who cared only about finding the lowest price.

My response was to suggest creating another business presence aimed at discount-oriented customers.

The idea was to develop a separate marketing channel for people who prioritize affordability.

That could allow the main business to maintain its existing positioning while reaching another segment of the market.

Using Separate Websites and Marketing Channels

For example, a parking lot striping company might operate a premium service brand that emphasizes comprehensive project management and quality.

It could also develop a clearly affiliated budget service offering for smaller, straightforward jobs.

Each could have its own website, advertising message, and phone number.

The premium brand could focus on customers who value service and reliability.

The budget offering could target customers who want a simpler service at a lower price.

The company could then compare the types of inquiries generated by each marketing channel.

That information might help it understand customer demand, improve scheduling, and adjust its services.

The critical point is to market the offerings truthfully.

Separate brands should not be used to fabricate independent competitors, misrepresent ownership, or create false impressions about competitive pricing.

Why Businesses Should Be Careful About Creating the Illusion of Competition

In the original moving company story, customers sometimes believed they were receiving quotes from two different companies.

That was part of what made the experience so memorable.

But it's also the part of the strategy I'd encourage business owners to approach carefully today.

Creating separate brands can be a legitimate marketing strategy.

However, using those brands to make customers believe they're comparing independent competitors when they're not can raise ethical, consumer protection, and advertising concerns.

You don't need to mislead customers to benefit from the underlying idea.

A Better Approach: Different Brands, Different Value Propositions

A company can operate multiple service brands while being transparent about their relationship.

For example, one brand might offer premium service packages.

Another might focus on smaller jobs with fewer extras.

Customers can choose the service level that best fits their needs.

The business still benefits from reaching different market segments.

And it can still measure demand through separate websites, phone numbers, and advertising campaigns.

The value comes from understanding customers, not from hiding who owns the company.

Another Example: A Stereo Store That Opened Its Own Competitor

The moving company wasn't the only example I encountered.

I also remember a story about a successful stereo retailer in Saint John, New Brunswick.

The owner was concerned that another retailer might enter the market.

So he opened a second stereo store under a different brand.

Both stores belonged to the same owner.

The businesses advertised against each other, creating attention around the local stereo market.

The competing advertisements generated excitement and encouraged customers to compare offers.

It was an unusual approach, but it demonstrated how multiple brands could influence customer attention.

Of course, the same transparency considerations apply.

The useful lesson is that different brands and messages can stimulate interest in a market.

That doesn't require misleading customers about the relationship between the businesses.

How to Apply Customer Segmentation to Your Small Business

If you're considering a similar strategy, I'd begin by examining your existing customers.

Ask yourself whether different groups are purchasing your services for different reasons.

You may discover opportunities that your current marketing doesn't address.

Here are five questions worth considering:

  1. Who are your most profitable customers? Understand what they value and why they choose your business.

  2. Who are you currently turning away? Some customers may want a simpler or less expensive service than your current offering.

  3. Do you have unused capacity? Additional work may make financial sense when employees or equipment would otherwise be idle, provided the pricing covers the relevant costs.

  4. Could different marketing messages attract different buyers? Test separate campaigns, landing pages, or clearly differentiated service offerings.

  5. Can you measure the results? Use dedicated phone numbers, inquiry tracking, and other analytics to understand which messages generate profitable customers.

The goal isn't simply to increase the number of inquiries.

It's to attract customers you can serve profitably while maintaining the positioning of your existing business.

Why Pricing Should Reflect Capacity and Customer Needs

One of the most valuable things the moving company owner learned was that pricing didn't need to remain identical under every circumstance.

If his schedule was full, he had little incentive to discount additional work.

But if a truck and crew were available for an otherwise empty afternoon, a smaller job might still make financial sense.

This is an important principle for service businesses.

Unused capacity can represent a lost opportunity.

However, lower-priced work should still contribute enough to justify the time, labor, equipment use, and other costs involved.

You don't want to fill your schedule with jobs that lose money.

And you don't want discount work to displace more profitable customers.

Understanding those trade-offs is part of managing a business effectively.

Final Thoughts: Sometimes Your Biggest Opportunity Is a Different Customer

Looking back on my Yellow Pages career, the moving company story remains one of my favorite examples of creative small business marketing.

We started with a simple observation.

Different customers were using the same directory in different ways.

Some wanted established, professional service providers.

Others wanted the lowest possible price.

By developing different advertisements for those groups, the moving company learned more about customer behavior and discovered opportunities to generate additional business.

As I said when remembering the experience:

"Learn the joy of bidding against yourself." —David C. Barnett

That was the memorable phrase behind the original strategy.

But the lasting business lesson is broader.

You don't always need to find a completely new market to grow your business. Sometimes you need a different way to reach customers who are already looking for the services you provide.

With modern websites, digital advertising, and call tracking, it's easier than ever to experiment with different messages and service offerings.

Just make sure the marketing is transparent and the economics make sense.

Because the real objective isn't to create the appearance of more competition.

It's to understand your customers, use your resources effectively, and build a more profitable business.

Learn More About Small Business Strategy and Valuation

If you own a business or are considering buying one, understanding customer behavior, pricing, profitability, and business value can help you make better decisions.

In my book Business and Asset Values, I explore how businesses and assets are valued and why understanding the alternatives matters when making investment decisions.

I also regularly share practical lessons from my experiences in sales, business ownership, and business brokerage.

👉 Want deeper dives like this? Join my email list at DavidCBarnettList.com for early access to videos, insights, and 7 free bonus gifts.


No comments:

Post a Comment