Would you rather buy a business that's growing 30% to 40% every year or one that's steadily growing at 10%?
At first glance, the faster-growing company sounds like the better opportunity. Revenue is climbing, profits are increasing, and the business appears to have plenty of momentum.
But does that make it a better acquisition?
Not necessarily.
Chris recently sent me a question about businesses experiencing sharp increases in revenue and net profit over three or four consecutive years. He wanted to know whether those companies were riskier than businesses with longer track records and more predictable growth.
It's a great question because rapid growth can signal an excellent acquisition opportunity, but it can also hide risks that aren't immediately obvious in the financial statements.
The important thing isn't simply how quickly the business is growing.
It's understanding why that growth is happening, whether it's sustainable, and what will happen after you become the owner.
Let's examine what buyers should look for when evaluating a fast-growing business.
Does Rapid Revenue Growth Make a Business More Valuable?
The answer depends on what's driving the growth.
Two businesses might both report a 40% increase in annual revenue, but the reasons behind those increases could be completely different.
One might be benefiting from temporary market conditions.
The other might be building a larger, more loyal customer base that continues generating revenue year after year.
Those aren't necessarily equally valuable opportunities.
Example 1: A Construction Company Winning Large Contracts
Imagine a construction company that has experienced significant growth because of an increase in major building projects.
The economy is strong, developers are investing, and the company has successfully bid on several large contracts.
Revenue and profit increase dramatically.
That sounds attractive.
But what happens when the business changes ownership?
The new owner still needs to compete for future projects.
They need to submit bids, maintain relationships with contractors, and convince customers that the company can deliver the required work.
The previous owner's success doesn't guarantee that future contracts will continue arriving.
A buyer might reasonably ask how much value exists in the company's historical earnings if winning the next project depends heavily on the new owner's efforts.
The business may have a good reputation, but the buyer needs to determine how transferable that reputation really is.
Example 2: A Retail Business With Thousands of Customers
Now consider a retail business serving thousands of customers who each spend relatively small amounts.
Suppose revenue increases consistently because more people are discovering the business.
Perhaps a nearby entertainment venue has started hosting more concerts and sporting events, bringing additional traffic into the neighborhood.
Or maybe the business introduced a new product or service that's attracting repeat customers.
That growth could be more sustainable.
The company may be strengthening its reputation and expanding its customer base.
As more customers become familiar with the business, its goodwill may become more valuable.
In that situation, a buyer might reasonably expect some of the growth to continue after the acquisition.
The distinction is important.
Growth driven by repeatable customer demand is different from growth that depends on repeatedly winning large, competitive contracts.
Neither situation is automatically good or bad, but they require different approaches to valuation.
The Most Important Question: Why Is the Business Growing?
Whenever I encounter a company reporting unusually strong growth, my first priority is understanding the cause.
I want to know where the additional revenue is coming from.
Has the company gained market share?
Has it introduced a successful new service?
Are customers spending more?
Or is the business benefiting from a temporary increase in demand?
You also need to understand whether the growth depends on something outside the company's control.
For example, a business serving customers involved in a particular investment trend might grow rapidly while that trend remains popular.
But what happens if public interest disappears?
In the video, I use businesses connected to cryptocurrency investing as an example.
A company serving that market might experience impressive growth during periods of intense investor interest.
But purchasing that company could also mean taking on significant exposure to the future popularity of cryptocurrency investing.
The buyer needs to understand that relationship.
Strong historical growth doesn't eliminate the risk that market conditions could change.
Rapid Growth Can Hide Operational Problems
Here's another issue buyers sometimes overlook.
A company can increase revenue without immediately increasing its operating expenses.
That can produce impressive profit growth.
But it doesn't necessarily mean those profit margins are sustainable.
What Happens When a Business Outgrows Its Resources?
Imagine a consulting business with a team capable of serving 50 clients.
Demand increases.
The company begins serving 70 clients, then 90.
Revenue climbs significantly.
But management hasn't hired additional employees.
Instead, the existing team is working longer hours and handling more responsibilities.
On paper, the company looks fantastic.
Revenue has increased while labor costs have remained relatively stable.
Profit margins improve.
But what's happening inside the business?
Employees may be exhausted.
Service quality might be deteriorating.
And the company may be approaching a point where it can't continue growing without additional investment.
The Hidden Cost of Hiring More Employees
Suppose you purchase that business based on its recent financial performance.
After closing, you discover that the existing employees can't sustain their workloads.
You need to hire two additional people.
Suddenly, the profitability you expected begins to disappear.
The seller's financial statements may have accurately reported the company's historical earnings.
But those earnings weren't necessarily sustainable under normal operating conditions.
That's why I want buyers to investigate whether the company has sufficient resources to support its current level of activity.
Ask about employee workloads, capacity, staffing needs, and operational bottlenecks.
You may discover that the business needs significant additional investment simply to maintain its existing revenue.
Watch Out for Sellers Who Are Working Unsustainable Hours
I've seen another version of this problem involving business owners themselves.
A seller knows that the value of their business is closely connected to profitability.
They also know that buyers are attracted to growth.
So they work harder.
They increase their hours from 40 to 50, then 60 or even 70 hours per week.
They take on more customers.
They push employees harder.
And they try to produce the strongest possible financial results before selling.
From the seller's perspective, that strategy might make sense.
But from the buyer's perspective, it creates a serious concern.
Can You Maintain the Seller's Performance?
Imagine buying a company where the owner has been working 70 hours every week.
Are you prepared to do the same?
If not, who will perform that additional work?
Will you need to hire someone?
And what will that do to the company's profitability?
A buyer shouldn't assume that the seller's most recent earnings will automatically continue under new ownership.
You need to understand the effort required to generate those earnings.
A business that appears to be growing rapidly might actually be operating beyond its sustainable capacity.
How Many Years of Earnings Should You Use to Value a Growing Business?
This is where rapid growth creates another complication.
When evaluating a business, buyers often examine several years of financial performance.
They may calculate an average or weighted average of earnings.
For example, a buyer might assign 60% weight to the most recent year, 30% to the previous year, and 10% to the year before that.
This can help smooth out variations in performance.
But what happens when a company is growing 40% annually?
A Fast-Growing Business Changes Quickly
If revenue and earnings are increasing dramatically every year, the business you're evaluating today may be materially different from the company that existed two or three years ago.
Older financial results may become less representative of current operations.
Naturally, the seller will want the valuation to reflect the company's latest performance.
They may even want buyers to consider the results being generated during the current fiscal year.
From the seller's perspective, that's understandable.
They're selling the business they own today, not the smaller company they operated three years ago.
But buyers have a different concern.
Buyers Don't Want to Pay for Future Growth They Must Create
A buyer may be reluctant to pay for earnings that haven't materialized yet.
Why?
Because the buyer will be responsible for operating the company and delivering those future results.
This is different from buying shares in a publicly traded company.
When you purchase stock in a large public company, you're generally investing in an organization with an established management team.
That team continues running the business after you invest.
When you acquire a small business, the existing owner may leave.
You could be taking responsibility for maintaining the company's performance yourself.
That makes future growth less certain.
And it's one reason buyers need to be cautious about paying for what I call blue sky—value based on optimistic expectations rather than demonstrated performance.
Why Fast-Growing Businesses Can Be Harder to Negotiate
Rapid growth doesn't just complicate valuation.
It can also make the transaction more difficult to complete.
I recently spoke with someone who was selling a business experiencing tremendous growth.
They had already received a letter of intent and were working through due diligence.
But only a few months had passed, and the company had continued growing.
The seller was beginning to feel that the agreed purchase price was too low.
The business was now producing substantially better results than it had when the offer was made.
From the buyer's perspective, the price might still seem reasonable.
From the seller's perspective, the deal was becoming less attractive.
The Longer the Deal Takes, the More the Seller May Reconsider
Imagine a seller who believes they could earn the equivalent of the purchase price by continuing to operate the business for another three years.
They agree to sell because they have personal reasons for wanting to exit.
But the company continues growing rapidly during due diligence.
A few months later, the seller might calculate that they could earn the same amount by keeping the business for only 18 months.
Now the decision looks different.
The seller may begin questioning whether selling is worthwhile.
And that can create problems for the buyer.
As I explain in the video, rapid growth can increase the concerns of both parties that they're making a mistake.
The buyer worries about overpaying.
The seller worries about selling too cheaply.
That uncertainty can make negotiations more volatile.
Why Steady-Growth Businesses Are Attractive to Buyers
Now let's consider the alternative.
A business that's been growing approximately 10% annually for several years.
That might sound less exciting than a company growing 40%.
But there are advantages.
Predictable Earnings Make Valuation Easier
When growth is relatively steady, buyers and sellers may find it easier to agree on a reasonable earnings figure.
A weighted average of recent years can provide a useful starting point.
The seller may not love the fact that older, lower earnings reduce the average.
But they can usually understand the reasoning.
There's also less concern that the business will become dramatically more valuable during a few months of due diligence.
That can make negotiations easier.
A Longer Track Record Can Build Confidence
Buyers often appreciate businesses that have demonstrated consistent performance over time.
They can examine how the company has handled different market conditions.
They can study customer relationships, operating expenses, and historical profitability.
And they may feel more confident about what the business will look like after the acquisition.
That doesn't mean steady growth guarantees safety.
It simply provides more evidence to evaluate.
You May Be Able to Create the Next Stage of Growth
There's another interesting opportunity with mature, steadily growing businesses.
Sometimes the seller is approaching retirement.
They may not be particularly interested in expanding.
They might be operating the company comfortably without investing much energy into new marketing or growth initiatives.
A motivated buyer could see opportunities to improve the business.
Perhaps there are services that could be added.
Maybe marketing could be improved.
Or the company could benefit from new systems and operational changes.
In that situation, you might acquire a profitable business at a reasonable price and create additional growth through your own efforts.
That's different from paying the seller today for growth you're hoping to achieve tomorrow.
How to Evaluate a Business With 30% to 40% Annual Growth
If you're considering buying a company with unusually strong recent growth, I'd focus on several important questions.
What's driving the growth? Determine whether it comes from new customers, existing customers, new products, temporary market conditions, or large one-time contracts.
Will the revenue continue after the seller leaves? Investigate customer relationships, reputation, contracts, and the seller's personal involvement.
Can the business sustain its current workload? Examine employee capacity, staffing levels, operating hours, and potential burnout.
What additional expenses will be required? Determine whether new employees, equipment, facilities, or other resources are needed to maintain current performance.
How should historical earnings be weighted? Consider whether older financial results remain representative of the business you're buying today.
Are you paying for demonstrated earnings or projected growth? Understand which portion of the purchase price is supported by existing performance.
Can the transaction be completed efficiently? Recognize that continuing growth may cause the seller to reconsider the agreed price during a lengthy process.
The goal isn't to avoid fast-growing companies.
It's to understand what you're buying and what will be required to keep the business performing.
Why Buyers Need to Be Ready to Move Quickly
When you've identified a fast-growing company that appears to be a good acquisition opportunity, time can become an important factor.
If you understand the business, have a clear acquisition strategy, and believe the valuation is reasonable, you should be prepared to move efficiently.
That doesn't mean rushing through due diligence or overlooking risks.
It means being organized.
Know what information you need.
Have your financing strategy ready.
And work toward completing the investigation without unnecessary delays.
The longer the transaction remains unresolved, the greater the opportunity for circumstances to change.
For a rapidly growing company, those changes may significantly affect the seller's willingness to proceed.
Don't Let Fear of Missing Out Drive Your Acquisition
There's one final point I want to emphasize.
When buyers encounter an attractive opportunity, they sometimes become convinced that they'll never find another one.
They begin chasing the deal.
They overlook warning signs.
And they may accept terms that don't make sense simply because they're afraid of losing the opportunity.
That's dangerous.
A business acquisition should fit your financial resources, skills, and goals.
If the numbers don't work, you need to be willing to walk away.
One of the things I emphasize in my Business Buyer Advantage training and group coaching is the importance of developing a consistent business search process.
When you have a system for finding and evaluating opportunities, you're less likely to become emotionally dependent on a single transaction.
You understand that other businesses may become available.
That gives you more confidence during negotiations.
And it helps you avoid buying something simply because you're afraid of missing out.
Final Thoughts: Is Fast Growth Better Than Steady Growth?
Let's return to Chris's original question.
Is a business growing 30% to 40% annually riskier than one growing steadily at 10%?
It depends.
A fast-growing company may be building a valuable customer base and developing a strong competitive position.
Or it may be benefiting from temporary market conditions, unsustainable employee workloads, or unusually aggressive efforts by an owner preparing to sell.
A slower-growing company may offer more predictable earnings and a longer operating history.
It may also provide opportunities for a new owner to introduce fresh energy and create additional growth.
Neither growth rate tells you enough on its own.
As I emphasized when answering Chris:
"We have to uncover why. Why is the revenue jumping like this?" —David C. Barnett
That's the question buyers need to answer.
Understand where the growth is coming from.
Determine whether it's sustainable.
And evaluate what will happen when the current owner leaves.
Because the best business acquisition isn't necessarily the company with the fastest-growing profits. It's the company whose future performance you can reasonably understand and whose risks you can manage.
Learn More About Evaluating Business Acquisitions
If you're considering buying a business, understanding earnings, valuation, growth trends, and operational risks can help you make better decisions.
Through my Business Buyer Advantage program, I teach buyers how to analyze opportunities, evaluate financial performance, negotiate transactions, and control acquisition risk.
I also share practical examples from real business acquisitions to help buyers understand what can happen during the search, negotiation, and due diligence process.
👉 Want deeper dives like this? Join my email list at DavidCBarnettList.com for early access to videos, insights, and 7 free bonus gifts.
No comments:
Post a Comment